Countries Object To U.S. Listing Them As Religious Freedom Violators

Uzbekistan's Ministry of Foreign Affairs last week issued a statement (full text) objecting to the country's inclusion on the U.S. State Department's list of countries of particular concern-- the most egregious violators of religious liberty. (See prior posting.) Charging that the U.S. takes a one-sided approach and uses a double standard, the statement says: "Religious toleration and forbearance have always been and remain to be the most important component of the state policy of the Republic of Uzbekistan. " It concludes that the State Department's action constitutes "interference into internal affairs of sovereign Uzbekistan". MosNews covers the story. Also last week, a spokesman for China's foreign ministry registered similar objections to his country's inclusion on this year's list. (Times of India).

Scottsdale Churches Oppose New Zoning Proposals

In Scottsdale, Arizona, a coalition of churches is opposing the most recent proposals by the city to restrict the location of new churches and religious schools. Yesterday's East Valley Tribune reported that the city is proposing that new schools in residential areas be at least a quarter-mile apart, and that "large assemblies" such as churches and religious schools be required to obtain a permit to operate in residential areas. The general proposals were a response to a suit filed by SonRise Community Church that was denied a permit to build a church and private school on a 9-acre site it owned. Church leaders say that the city's proposals would prohibit a church from founding an on-premise school if another school was close by. They also fear that the permit requirement will let the city regulate when services can be held and how large churches can grow. Scottsdale leaders are now drafting a white paper to try to come up with a compromise. They plan to release the compromise proposals next Friday. (See prior related posting.)

Episcopal Church Has Task Force On Property Disputes

The Episcopal Church is sufficiently concerned over defections by traditionalists who object to church policies such as the 2003 ordination of an openly gay bishop that it has formed a special task force to monitor dioceses that it considers a problem. The Associated Press reports that the House of Bishops Task Force on Property Disputes is remaining in contact with Episcopalians who want to remain loyal to the Episcopal Church in at least six dioceses that have distanced themselves from policies of the national body. The goal is to be ready for legal battles that may ensue.

Poll Finds No Difference In Religiosity In Muslim Radicals and Moderates

This month's Foreign Policy carries an article titled What Makes a Muslim Radical?. It reports on a Gallup World Poll of more than 9,000 interviews in nine Muslim countries. The poll shows that Muslim radicals have more in common with Muslim moderates than previously thought. It finds that there is no significant difference in religiosity, or attendance at religious services, between moderates and radicals. The main difference between the two groups seems to be that radicals are more likely to feel that the West threatens and attempts to control their way of life, while moderates want to build economic ties with the West.

Movement To Legalize Polygamy In US

The Providence (RI) Journal yesterday carried an article on the movement in the United States to legalize polygamy. A sign of their progress is the fact that Utah's attorney general, Mark Shurtleff, no longer prosecutes bigamy between consenting adults. He has promoted meetings between Utah law enforcement officials and representatives of polygamous groups. Shurtleff does go after members of polygamous groups that violate other laws such as rape laws and laws prohibiting sexualcontactst with minors.

British Muslim Teacher Who Insisted On Veil Is Dismissed

Aishah Azmi, the teaching assistant in a British school who brought high profile litigation last month in her attempt to veil her face while teaching children (see prior posting), has now been dismissed from her position. After claiming that her religious beliefs meant she had to wear a niqab in the presence of male colleagues, including when working with pupils, she was suspended without pay by Headfield Church of England School, in Dewsbury, West Yorks. School officials claimed that the veil interfered with her ability to communicate with students. (See prior posting.) An employment tribunal rejected her claim of discrimination, but awarded her damages for injury to her feelings. Her one-year fixed term contract was renewed in August, even though she had been suspended for the past six months. But now, after a disciplinary hearing before education officials, she has been terminated, according to yesterday's Telegraph. Her lawyers are waiting for a written decision before they decide whether to appeal.

25th Anniversary Of UN Declaration On Religious Freedom

Today is the 25th anniversary of the adoption by the United Nations of the Declaration on the Elimination of All Forms of Intolerance and of Discrimination Based on Religion or Belief. Marking the day, the United States Commission on International Religious Freedom called on countries around the world to review their policies in order to promote religious freedom and support the work of the United Nations and other international bodies in this area.

Sect Leaders Convicted For Resisting Restaurant Inspection

In Costa Mesa, California, three members of a small born-again Christian religious sect were convicted this week on multiple misdemeanor counts for refusing to let health inspectors into their tea room to carry out a normally-routine restaurant inspection. The Associated Press today reports that the Piecemakers have resisted health inspectors since the early 1990's, arguing that the law of God takes precedence over the law of man. Inspectors say the Piecemakers are selling unpackaged foods, such as homemade sandwiches and soup, without a permit. They were ordered to stop doing so and placed on probation in 2000, but undercover inspectors found continuing violations. Last October, inspectors arrived with a court order and faced a loud confrontation. 85-year old Marie Kolasinski and two others were arrested after they wrestled with inspectors and let loose with a barrage of profanity. Defendants each face up to a year in jail.

Indiana Released-Time Suit Nears Settlement

A settlement appears to have been reached in a law suit filed last month by the ACLU of Indiana against the Mooresville, Indiana school system challenging the Weekday Religious Education Program offered to Neil Armstrong Elementary School students. (See prior posting.) The Indy Star today reports that the primary concern of the parents challenging the released-time program has been met by moving the voluntary weekly classes from a trailer on school property to a church across the street.

Yemeni Editor Sentenced For Publishing Mohammed Cartoons

A court in Yemen today found newspaper editor Kamal al-Olufi guilty of "publishing blasphemous drawings offending the Prophet Mohammed and Islamic religion." The controversial cartoons were first run in a Danish newspaper last year. M&C News reports that al-Olufi was sentenced to one year in prison, and a six-month ban was imposed on his newspaper for violations of Yemen's Press and Publications Law.

Marine Now In Iraq Sues As Conscientious Objector

A Philadelphia Inquirer story from yesterday reports that a habeas corpus action has been filed in federal court in Washington, D.C. on behalf of Marine Lance Corporal John Rogowskyj, Jr. The Pennsylvania man is seeking to be discharged as a conscientious objector. The 22-year old Marine who joined the National Guard in 2002, says he is a religious humanist who does not belong to any organized religion. His CO claim was rejected by a C.O. Status Screening Board in August. The Board said it believed that his claim was merely a means to avoid deployment to Iraq. He was deployed to Iraq on Nov. 2 in a non-combat assignment—serving on an armed patrol boat protecting hydroelectric plants along the Tigris and Euphrates Rivers and Lake Qadisiyah.

Turkey In Uncertain Times On Relation of Islam To State as Pope's Visit Nears

Pope Benedict XVI will visit Turkey next week. The Los Angeles Times reports that many Muslims in the country remain angry over the Pope’s speech in Regensburg, Germany last September that was seen by many as unfairly critical of Islam. (See prior posting.) Turkey’s Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdogan, who will be away at a NATO summit during part of the Pope’s visit, will not be meeting with the Pope. The Pope’s planned visit to Istanbul's St. Sophia, built in the 6th century as a Byzantine church and converted into a mosque 900 years later, has also created controversy as an Islamic newspaper charged that the Pope was planning to bless the former church in an attempt to "revive Byzantium". Actually, the main purpose of the Pope’s trip is to bridge the split between the Vatican and the world’s Orthodox Christians led by Ecumenical Patriarch Bartholomew I in Istanbul. (Houston Chronicle).

This week, Turkey’s leading think tank, the Turkish Economic and Social Studies Foundation, released a poll suggesting that political Islam is not taking hold in the country. It shows that while religion is flourishing in Turkey, it is undergoing modernization and liberalization. (Turkish Weekly.)

Meanwhile, in what is seen as a precedent-setting decision, a Turkish court this week ruled that a student who was a member of Turkey’s Alevi community was exempt from mandatory religion courses taught in Turkish schools. The case was brought by Ali Kenanoglu, Deputy Chairman of the Alevi-Bektashi Foundation, in order to get the exemption for his son. Turkey’s Religious Affairs Directorate has insisted that Alevis are not members of a separate religious faith. In a separate case, an appeal is pending before the European Court of Human Rights by an Alevi challenging mandatory religion classes in Turkish schools. (Reports from Sabah and from the Turkish Daily News.)

UPDATE: Zenit on Sunday carried an interesting interview with Raphaela M.T. Schmid, the Rome director of the Becket Institute for Religious Liberty on The State of Religious Liberty in Turkey. She says: "Christian churches want more religious freedom but they too are aware that the secularism of the Turkish state may also be a bulwark against a more radical form of Islam."

Religious Bias Claim Growing Out Of Child Neglect Proceeding Moves Ahead

In Starkey v. Boulder County Social Services, 2006 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 84768 (D CO, Nov. 21, 2006), a Colorado federal district court permitted a husband and wife and their children to move forward with their claim against state social workers. Plaintiffs alleged that the defendants during the course of a Colorado state court dependency and neglect proceeding took action to deprive plaintiff parents of custody and visitation rights, motivated by disapproval of their fundamentalist Christian beliefs. The court dismissed claims against the social service agency itself on 11th Amendment grounds, but permitted claims against individual defendants to proceed over their claim of qualified immunity.

Hong Kong Court Upholds Regulation Of Religious Schools Getting State Aid

The High Court of Hong Kong yesterday decided Catholic Diocese of Hong Kong v. Secretary for Justice, (HCAL 157/2005, Nov. 23, 2006), upholding a 2004 law on the governance of religious schools receiving state aid in Hong Kong. Hong Kong's Basic Law protects the right of religious organizations to continue to run seminaries and other schools "according to their previous practice". The Catholic Diocese challenged the requirement that school management committees be set up, and that sponsoring religious bodies are only permitted to appoint 60% of the committee members. The court held that educational institutions’ autonomy must be subject to the policies formulated by the Government of the Hong Kong under article 136(1) of the Basic Law that gives the government the power to "formulate policies on the development and improvement of education". China's The Standard today reports at length on the decision and says the diocese has not said whether it plans an appeal.

Pakistan Senate Follows Lower House In Passing Hudood Amendments

Following the lead of the National Assembly (see prior posting), Pakistan's Senate yesterday passed amendments to the country's Hudood Ordinance, allowing rape cases to be tried in criminal courts instead of Islamic courts, and eliminating the death penalty for persons convicted of having sex outside of marriage. The International Herald Tribune reported that the bill, passed by voice vote, now goes to President Pervez Musharraf, who is expected to sign it into law. The International News gives more detail on the debate in the Senate on the law, known as the Women's Protection Bill.

Christian Converts Go On Trial In Turkey

The Associated Press reports that two men who converted to Christianity went on trial yesterday in Turkey, charged under Article 301 of Turkey's Penal Code with insulting "Turkishness" and inciting religious hatred against Islam. The charges against the men include telling potential converts that Islam was "a primitive and fabricated" religion and that Turks would remain "barbarians" as long they continued practicing Islam; speaking out against Turkey's compulsory military service; and compiling databases of possible converts. The trial began just a few days before Pope Benedict XVI visits the country.

Ontario Group Complains About City Council Prayer

In the Canada, the group Secular Ontario has examined the minutes of council meetings posted online by Ontario towns and cities and has found 18 municipalities that open their meetings with the Lord's Prayer. Yesterday's Ottawa Sun reported that the group has sent the list to Municipal Affairs and Housing Minister John Gerretsen and has written the municipalities involved pointing out that a 1999 Ontario Court of Appeals decision (Freitag v. Corporation of the Town of Penetanguishene) held that the practice violates Canada's Charter of Rights and Freedoms.

Court Avoids Interesting RLUIPA Constitutional Issue

A Georgia federal district court has avoided deciding an intriguing constitutional challenge to the Religious Land Use and Institutionalized Persons Act. In Williams v. Georgia, 2006 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 80852 (SD GA, Nov. 6, 2006), a federal judge accepted in full a Magistrate Judge's Report and Recommendation, 2006 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 84023 (SD GA, Oct. 10, 2006), denying prison officials' motion to dismiss a RLUIPA claim against them. The prisoner's substantive complaints were fairly routine-- the prison's refusal to furnish him a pork-free diet and the requirement that he shave his head and beard violate his right to practice his religious beliefs. The unusual part of the case was the defense raised by prison officials to the portion of the suit brought against them in their individual capacities.

The defendants argued that the constitutional basis for RLUIPA is Congress' spending clause power, and the individual officials are not part of the contract for spending between the Department of Corrections and the federal government. However the court held that since plaintiff's claims are only against the individual defendants in their official capacities, it is unnecessary for the court to decide the more difficult question of whether RLUIPA authorizes suit against government officials in their individual capacities. (See prior related posting.)

D.C. Officials Say Religious Group Needs Fraternity House Zoning

Just before Thanksgiving, Washington, D.C.'s Zoning Administrator found himself in the midst of a dispute with nine college students over the line between a religious organization and a fraternity house. Yesterday's Washington Post reports that in August, student Brian O'Neill Jr. and eight friends moved into an elegant house in Georgetown where zoning rules restrict occupancy to six unrelated people. The students, however, filed to incorporate as the Apostles of Peace and Unity, a non-profit religious organization-- a move that some of their parents described as "ingenious". Religious groups are exempt from the six-person limitation. However, at the instance of unhappy neighbors, D.C. zoning officials have issued a cease-and-desist order against the students, saying they fit the definition of a fraternity house and therefore require a zoning variance and additional designated parking spaces.

Scientologists' Gifts To London Police Questioned

The British press has disclosed that London police officers have accepted gifts and entertainment worth thousands of pounds from the Church of Scientology. Reuters on Wednesday reported that the police department has opened a review of its hospitality policy after it was disclosed that invitations to charity dinners, music concerts and a film premiere were among the gifts, most of which were approved by senior officers. Police apparently developed a relationship with Scientologists when the group helped police last July in dealing with the suicide attacks on the London transit system.