Article Explores Accommodation of Religious Anti-Gay Workplace Expression

An article in today's New York Law Journal explores the difficulties raised for employers under the New York Human Right Law in accommodating employees who regard workplace expression of beliefs against homosexuality as a religious duty. Author Judith Moldover says: "The conflict between sexual orientation discrimination and the duty to accommodate religious bias against homosexuals typically arises in three types of situations: refusal to service homosexual clients, refusal to participate in diversity programs and training, and supervisory conduct."

Supreme Court Hears Arguments In Prisoner's Tort Claims Act Case

Yesterday the U.S. Supreme Court heard arguments (full transcript) in the case of Ali v. Federal Bureau of Prison, 06-9130. At issue is whether a suit for damages can be brought under the Federal Tort Claims Act (FTCA) by a Muslim inmate who claims that prison officials mishandled his prayer rug and two copies of the Koran. They are among items that are missing after inmate Abdus-Shahid Ali was transferred from a prison in Atlanta to one in Kentucky. The government argues that Ali should be limited to filing an administrative complaint for the items lost in transit. (Associated Press.) The 11th Circuit Court of Appeals below dismissed Ali's claim because 28 USC Sec. 2680(c) provides that the waiver of sovereign immunity in the FTCA does not extend to claims for the detention of property. Circuits are split over whether this provision applies to suits against all government officials, or only to suits against officers acting in a tax, excise, or customs capacity. (Questions presented.) The merit briefs in the case are also available online. [Thanks to How Appealing for the lead.]

As Halloween Approaches, Paper Recounts 17th Century Witch Trials

As Halloween approaches, today's Idaho Statesman recounts the history of four different witch trials in 17th century New England. Rebecca Bowen-Odom, a descendant of one of those tried, argues that the strange behavior of women in those days may have been caused by egot fungus poisoning. Ergot was used by 17th century midwives to hasten childbirth.

Canadian Prime Minister Meets With Dalai Lama For First Time

Canadian Prime Minister Stephen Harper yesterday became the first Canadian prime minister to hold an official meeting with the Dalai Lama. CTA.ca reports that the Chinese embassy in Ottawa has protested the meeting, saying: "It is a blatant interference in China's internal affairs and has severely hurt the feelings of the Chinese people." Earlier in the day, the Dalai Lama praised Canada's multiculturalism, urging China's leaders to learn from Canada's "promotion of unity based on mutual respect." The meeting follows a first-time public appearance between a U.S. president and the Dalai Lama earlier this month. (See prior posting.)

Recent Prisoner Religious Exercise Cases In U.S. and Britain

In Ashmore v. Frank, 2007 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 79235 (WD WI, Oct. 23, 2007), a prisoner claimed that while he was in temporary lockup for 26 days he was denied use of his Bible and attendance at religious services. A Wisconsin federal district court ruled that he can proceed with his claim if he amends his complaint to identify the individual defendants personally involved in the deprivation.

Singh v. Goord, 2007 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 78742 (SDNY, Oct. 9, 2007), involved a challenge by a Sikh prisoner to various policies of the new York Department of Corrections, attempting to obtain greater accommodation of a number of Sikh religious practices. Some of the claims were dismissed for failure to exhaust administrative remedies. However, the court permitted plaintiff to move ahead on his claim that he should be permitted to wear the kara (steel bracelet) and khanda (pendant), possess a second kanga (religious comb), possess longer turbans, remain in contact with religious articles during searches, and that prison religious exercise policies should be re-written to include Sikhs. It granted plaintiff summary judgment on separate packing and storage of his scriptures. It granted defendants summary judgment allowing them to require plaintiff to pray quietly instead of out loud, upholding the vegetarian diet plaintiff is now served, and permitting the identity card maintained by prison authorities.

In Britain, Muslim prisoners at a high security facility in Leeds are suing for $20 million in damages because of a mistake in the Ramadan menu. CFP yesterday reported that the menu offered ham sandwiches as one of the options. Ministry of Justice officials say it was merely a printing mistake, but some inmates claim they actually received ham sandwiches when they ordered cheese sandwiches, and that some were so hungry that they ate the religiously forbidden ham.

Israeli Rabbinate Threatens To Fine Zionist Rabbinical Group

In Israel yesterday, the Chief Rabbinate's legal counsel said he would press to have the Rabbinate impose fines on Tzohar, the organization of Zionist rabbis that is moving to implement an alternative certification process for produce grown in Israel during the current sabbatical year. Today's Jerusalem Post quotes Chief Rabbinate Legal Advisor Shimon Ulman: "We can't allow every Dr. Jekyl and Mr. Hyde to open his own kosher supervision outfit." However the director general of the Chief Rabbinate was more cautious, saying that technically the Tzohar rabbis are not violating the Kashrut Fraud Law. If implemented by the Chief Rabbinate, an order of the Israeli Supreme Court issued last week will moot the controversy. The court ordered the Chief Rabbinate to override local rabbis and certify as kosher produce grown on land technically "sold" to a non-Jew during the sabbatical year (heter mechira). (See prior posting.) [Thanks to Joel Katz for the lead.]

Italian Church Groups Evicting Tenants To Get Higher Rents

Rising rents in Italy, particularly in Rome, have led landlords to refuse to renew many residential leases at their current rates. A temporary law has blocked some landlords from evicting low-income families with children and households with members who are elderly, seriously disabled or terminally ill. However the law does not apply to ecclesiastical bodies. Today's Guardian reports that several thousand residents in Rome are about to be evicted from properties owned by religious orders, papal colleges and foundations originally set up for charitable purposes. A tenants' organization has written a letter of protest to Archbishop Angelo Bagnasco, head of the Italian bishops' conference, who last month delivered a widely-reported speech protesting the lack of low-cost housing for pensioners and single-income families who are being evicted.

TRO Against Anti-Muslim Group Extended

Yesterday a federal district court in Dallas, Texas extended an earlier temporary restraining order against Joe Kaufman and his organization, Americans Against Hate. The original TRO was aimed at planned protests at Six Flags Amusement Park during Muslim Family Day at the park earlier this month. The TRO barred Kaufman from threatening members of various Muslim organizations. Kaufman had used his website to encourage protests against sponsors of the Family Day who he referred to as "radicals", "extremists" and "jihadists", because of their connection to the Holy Land Foundation, a group listed as an unindicted co-conspirator in the recent Holy Land Foundation terrorism financing case. Today's Dallas Morning News reports that in obtaining an extension of the TRO, plaintiffs' attorney Don Fulton argued that Muslim groups are still being targeted on Mr. Kaufman’s Web site. Kaufman has posted photos and addresses of local mosques affiliated with the North American Islamic Trust. Fulton says this encourages violence against them. The court rejected Kaufman's argument that it lacked personal jurisdiction over him.

Military Funeral Flag Script Dropped After Objection To Jewish References

At military funerals, it has been a tradition if requested by the family for the honor guard to fold the flag that covered the veteran's coffin 13 times and to recite a script developed by veterans' groups that suggests an inspirational meaning for each fold. Now, according to Friday's Military Times, the National Cemetery Administration has banned the ceremony at all funerals after receiving a complaint about the language describing the 11th fold: "The eleventh fold, in the eyes of a Hebrew citizen, represents the lower portion of the seal of King David and King Solomon, and glorifies, in their eyes, the God of Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob." The Chico (CA) Enterprise Record says that the complaint originated with a funeral at Southern California's Riverside National Cemetery.

The script accompanying the 12th fold also mentions religion: "The twelfth fold, in the eyes of a Christian citizen, represents an emblem of eternity and glorifies, in their eyes, God the Father, the Son, and Holy Ghost." Last July, the Air Force secularized the script used at its funerals. (See prior posting.) [Thanks to Scott Mange for the lead.]

Breakaway Presbyterians In Ohio Keep Church Property

In November 2006, members of the Hudson (OH) Presbyterian Church voted 166-61 to disaffiliate from the Presbyterian Church USA. It has since been operating independently, but two weeks ago voted to affiliate with the New Wineskins Association of Churches. After the vote-- which was prompted by disagreements over theological and policy issues-- those remaining loyal to the PCUSA were designated by the Eastminster Presbytery as the true Hudson Presbyterian Church. However, according to the Akron Beacon Journal, a Summit County Common Pleas Court magistrate ruled on Friday that the church's property belongs to the majority breakaway group. Magistrate John Shoemaker rejected the argument that the church property was held in trust for the denomination as defined in the PCUSA constitution. The decision is consistent with one by a New Hampshire court earlier this month. (See prior posting.)

UPDATE: Here is the full text of the magistrate's opinion in Hudson Presbyterian Church v. Eastminster Presbytery, (OH Com. Pl., Summit Co., Oct. 23, 2007). [Thanks to Ed Koster for sending along the opinion.]

UPDATE: The Christian Post on Monday reports on the fourth annual Convocation of the New Wineskins Association of Churches beig held this week. It will create a non-geographical Transitional Presbytery for the increasing number of congregations leaving the PCUSA to seek New Wineskins membership.

Prisoner Claim Raises Holiday Decoration Issue In New Context

An obscure prisoner case has raised the issue of holiday decorations in a new context. In Spence v. Federal Correctional Institute, 2007 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 75398 (WD LA, Oct. 9, 2007), affirming Magistrate's recommendation and report, 2007 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 77617 (WD LA, Sept. 12, 2007), a prisoner claimed that his free exercise rights had been violated when an officer at a federal correctional facility in Pennsylvania ordered him to assist with installation of a Santa Clause and reindeer being put up in the prison as holiday decorations. Eugene Spence said that assisting was in conflict with his beliefs as a Muslim and requested another job assignment. However prison authorities refused, saying that the decorations were non-denominational. In this decision, the court merely transferred the case from Louisiana to a Pennsylvania federal court, thus temporarily avoiding the merits of the claim.

Some Wisconsin Amish Object To Obtaining Building Permits

Sunday's LaCrosse, Wisconsin Tribune reports on a small group of conservative Amish in Albion, Wisconsin who object on religious grounds to taking out building permits before constructing homes or driveways. Eric Gove, an Amish friend of some of the objectors, says that Amish beliefs create problems with granting officials a right of inspection. Some also object to signing the permit because it violates the Biblical verse in 2 Corinthians that reads: "Be not unequally yoked together with non-believers." Beginning in July, the town cited five Amish men for noncompliance with permit requirements, which could lead to fines of $10 to $1000 per day.

Recent Articles of Interest

From SSRN:

• Martha Jane Bailey, Beverley Baines & Bita Amani, Expanding Recognition of Foreign Polygamous Marriages: Policy Implications for Canada, (Queen's Univ. Legal Studies Research Paper No. 07-12, 2006).


• Muriel Morisey, Flag Desecration, Religion and Patriotism, (Rutgers Journal of Law and Religion, Vol. 9, 2007).


• Robert A. Sedler, Essay: The Protection of Religious Freedom under the American Constitution, (Wayne State University Law School Research Paper No. 07-37).


• Benjamin Straumann, The Peace of Westphalia (1648) as a Secular Constitution, (September 2007).

Other:

• Journal of Church and State , Vol 49, No. 3 (Summer 2007) has recently been published.

Roots of Spain's Church-State Tensions Go Back to Spanish Civil War

In Spain, tensions between the Catholic Church and the country's current Socialist government revive tensions and memories from the bloody Spanish Civil war of 70 years ago. Today's Los Angeles Times reports that in addition to the offering of classes in Catholicism under an arrangement that dates back to post-Civil War rule of Francisco Franco, Spain's government has now introduced a new mandatory "education for citizenship" course. The Church claims that the new offering contradicts Church teachings by advocating the acceptance of homosexuals. The church's liaison to the Education Ministry, Sister Maria Rosa de la Cierva, says: "This is a frontal assault on the Catholic religion. This is an authentic scholastic war . . . and part of a clear persecution, little by little, of the Catholic faith." The Church wants students to be able to opt out of the new course, and several months ago LifeSite News reported that at least some religiously-operated schools are offering that option.

Meanwhile, in another move that heightens tensions, USA Today reports that the Vatican has beatified 498 victims of the anti-Catholic persecution that began in 1931 and became an excuse for Nationalists to launch a rebellion that ultimately placed Franco in power. This declaration of martyrdom comes just three days before Spain's Parliament is to enact a Socialist-sponsored law that will condemn Franco and call for the removal of tributes to him around the country. (See prior posting.) The ceremony today in St. Peter's Square in Rome is the largest mass beatification ceremony the Church has ever held.

Catholic Bishops Debating Draft Of Election Year Guide

Saturday's New York Times discusses the challenge facing Catholic bishops when the meet in Baltimore next month to consider the draft of their 2008 statement on political responsibilities of Catholics. This election year's draft is titled "Forming Consciences for Faithful Citizenship". The bishops do not want this to be a partisan voters' guide. However debate looms on how prominent the abortion issue should be in the guide as well as on why the war in Iraq is not a more prominent part of the statement. The guide, issued each Presidential election year since 1976, regularly deals with a broad range of social issues.

Canadian Bill Would Require Muslim Women To Uncover Face Before Voting

In the Canadian Parliament on Friday, the government introduced a bill that would require all voters, including veiled Muslim women, to identify themselves with their faces uncovered in order to vote. Bill C-6 provides an exemption only when uncovering one's face would be harmful to the prospective voter's health. Reporting on the bill, Friday's Toronto Globe & Mail indicated that election officials would have flexibility in administering the law in order to respect religious beliefs. For example, Elections Canada could allow Muslim women to uncover their faces behind a screen with only a female elections official present. The introduction of the bill follows political criticism of Quebec's election officials who said they would permit women wearing a niqab to identify themselves with their faces covered. (See prior related posting.)

Kansas Supreme Court Temporarily Halts Grand Jury Probing Abortion Provider

The state of Kansas has a provision that requires a grand jury to be summoned in a county upon a petition of 100 plus 2% of the total number of votes cast for governor in the county in the last election. (K.S.A. § 22-3001). Following the lead of Sedgwick County citizens, a coalition of anti-abortion groups has just filed a petition to impanel a grand jury in Johnson County, Kansas to investigate whether a Planned Parenthood clinic has violated the state's abortion law. (Background). Meanwhile, according to the Kansas City Star, on Friday the Kansas Supreme Court issued an order temporarily blocking the Sedgwick County grand jury convened in this manner from proceeding. Wichita abortion provider George Tiller, the object of the investigation, alleged that the proceedings amount to harassment. The Supreme Court ordered two Sedgwick County judges to respond to Tiller's petition to the Supreme Court.

No Free Exercise Issue In Church's Flea Market Restrictions

In Shaffer v. Jones, 2007 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 79117 (ND IN, Oct. 5, 2007), an Indiana federal district court dismissed free exercise and equal protection claims brought against the the manager of a flea market, holding that the manager was a private individual and was not acting under color of law. The market apparently was operated by the Embassies of Christ Church. Plaintiff James Shaffer alleged that the manager, Jerwan Jones, told him that he worshiped a false God and was going to hell. Jones warned Shaffer that if he did not remove all non-Christian items from his booth space, he would no longer be allowed to operate at the market. The court said: "The Constitution does not prevent a church from restricting the message presented at an event it is running."

UN Religious Freedom Official Worries About Abuse of Religious Power

Two recent speeches by Asma Jahangir, the United Nations Special Rapporteur for Freedom of Religion or Belief, are in the news as the UN official expresses concern about blasphemy laws and about illegal conduct undertaken in the name of religion.

In an Oct. 25 speech to the NGO, Committee for Freedom of Religion or Belief, she warned against countries going too far in banning defamation against religion. According to the Adventist News Network, Jahangir argued that "objective criticism" of religion is a human right, and expressed concern that blasphemy laws can be used to silence dissent. She also rejected analogies between racial hatred and religious hatred, saying: "religion is unlike race -- you cannot proselytize to change [your] race. There are serious differences."

Speaking on Oct. 26 before the General Assembly’s Social, Humanitarian and Cultural (Third) Committee, Jahangir warned against the use of religion as an excuse for criminal action that encroaches on the rights of others. A UN News Centre release quotes her: "No impunity should be awarded when criminal acts which infringe on the human rights of others are given a religious label. At the same time, all governmental actions should be proportionate, abide by the rule of law and respect the applicable international human rights standards."

NYT Article Focuses On Splits In Evangelical Movement

Today's New York Times Magazine carries a feature article by David D. Kirkpatrick titled The Evangelical Crackup. It discusses at length generational and theological splits in the evangelical Christian movement. Here is an excerpt:

For the conservative Christian leadership, what is most worrisome about the evangelical disappointment with President Bush is that it coincides with a widening philosophical rift. Ever since they broke with the mainline Protestant churches nearly 100 years ago, the hallmark of evangelicals theology has been a vision of modern society as a sinking ship, sliding toward depravity and sin. For evangelicals, the altar call was the only life raft — a chance to accept Jesus Christ, rebirth and salvation. Falwell, Dobson and their generation saw their political activism as essentially defensive, fighting to keep traditional moral codes in place so their children could have a chance at the raft.

But many younger evangelicals — and some old-timers — take a less fatalistic view. For them, the born-again experience of accepting Jesus is just the beginning. What follows is a long-term process of “spiritual formation” that involves applying his teachings in the here and now. They do not see society as a moribund vessel. They talk more about a biblical imperative to fix up the ship by contributing to the betterment of their communities and the world. They support traditional charities but also public policies that address health care, race, poverty and the environment.