Objective coverage of church-state and religious liberty developments, with extensive links to primary sources.
Friday, November 16, 2007
NY High Court Dismisses Orthodox Jew's Privacy Claim As Time-Barred
Yesterday in Nussenzweig v. diCorcia, (NY Ct. App., Nov. 15, 2007), New York's highest court agreed with a majority in the Appellate Division (see prior posting) that the statute of limitations barred a Hasidic Jew from suing a professional photographer who took his photo without consent. Photographer Philip-Lorca DiCorcia took a series of photographs of people in Times Square, including Erno Nussenzweig, and used the photos in a gallery exhibition and accompanying catalogue. Nussenzweig's interpretation of the Biblical ban against making graven images was violated by the use of the photo. The court held that New York's "single publication rule" should be applied to right of privacy actions under the state's civil rights law (Sec. 50 and 51), so that the cause of action accrued on the date the offending material was first published. Haaretz reports on the decision.
7th Circuit Rejects School Counsellor's Religious Discrimination Claim
In Grossman v. South Shore Public School District, (7th Cir., Nov. 15, 2007), the U.S. 7th Circuit Court of Appeals affirmed the district court's rejection of a First Amendment and Title VII religious discrimination claim brought by a school guidance counsellor. The school denied plaintiff tenure because, without consulting her supervisors, she destroyed literature on condom use and replaced it with literature advocating abstinence. Plaintiff had also urged two students who came to her for advice to pray with her. The court concluded that plaintiff was not denied tenure because of her religious beliefs, but instead because of her actions. The court declared: "Teachers and other public school employees have no right to make the promotion of religion a part of their job description." The 7th Circuit's website also links to an audio recording of oral arguments in the case presented last September.
Preliminary Injunction Issued To Permit Gideons To Distribute Bibles Near Schools
In Gray v. Kohl, (SD FL, Nov. 14, 2007), a Florida federal district court adopted a magistrate's earlier Report and Recommendation (June 29, 2007) and issued a preliminary injunction against enforcing Florida's School Safety Zone Statute against a Gideon who had been distributing Bibles within 500 feet of a Key Largo school. (See prior posting.) The magistrate's report concluded that the law was unconstitutionally vague, in particular because of the uncertainty of what constitutes having "legitimate business" near a school. Alliance Defense Fund issued a release praising the decision.
Thursday, November 15, 2007
Senator Says Defy China's One Bible Limit At Olympics
CNS News reports that Colorado Senator Ken Salazar, in a Cybercast News interview (audio), said that Americans travelling to the Beijing Olympics next year should defy China's requirement that travellers bring no more than one Bible into the country. Wang Hui, executive deputy director of the Beijing Organizing Committee for the Olympic Games, has described the policy as one permitting athletes and travellers to bring their own Bibles, but not multiple copies for public distribution.
Strip Club Owner Sues Church and County Sheriff
Today's Zanesville, Ohio Times Recorder reports on a lawsuit pending in federal district court in Columbus (OH). In Nellie, Ohio, members of the New Beginnings Ministries have been conducting weekly picketing of a strip club known as the Foxhole. Foxhole owner, Thomas George, has filed suit against the church and its members seeking damages and an injunction. George also claims that Coshocton County Sheriff Tim Rogers has violated his rights by refusing to remove protesters from his property and refusing to file trespassing charges against them. Thomas Condit, attorney for the church, says that church members are merely exercising their First Amendment rights to advise the public "not to patronize a business they think is unhealthy and immoral." Last week the church filed a counter-claim alleging that an explosion last July in a dumpster outside of the Foxhole was aimed at threatening or injuring protesters.
Post-Trial Motions Filed In Westboro Funeral Picketing Case
In a Baltimore, Maryland federal district court, anti-gay Westboro Baptist Church and its leaders are asking the court to overturn the jury's recent $10.9 million award against them and to stay enforcement of the judgment pending appeal of the case. The verdict came in a suit by the father of a Marine whose funeral was picketed by church members. Yesterday's Baltimore Sun reported that the request was made last week in a post-trial motion arguing that the verdict was "the product of passion, prejudice and bias, based specifically and exclusively upon disagreement with defendants' religion." Meanwhile, today's Baltimore Sun reports that in records considered by the jury in assessing damages, Westboro Baptist Church and its three leaders who were sued said that their net worth is just under $1 million. Plaintiff intends to challenge the accuracy of these figures. Financial information will be important as the trial judge considers motions to reduce the jury awards.
UPDATE: In an unusual move, defendants on Nov. 9 also filed a writ of mandamus with the U.S. Supreme Court seeking review of the constitutional questions involved in the case. (AP). It appears unlikely that the Supreme Court will intervene at this early stage. [Thanks to First Amendment Law Prof Blog for the lead.]
UPDATE: In an unusual move, defendants on Nov. 9 also filed a writ of mandamus with the U.S. Supreme Court seeking review of the constitutional questions involved in the case. (AP). It appears unlikely that the Supreme Court will intervene at this early stage. [Thanks to First Amendment Law Prof Blog for the lead.]
Court Hears Arguments Over Memorial Crosses On Public Land
Today's Salt Lake Tribune reports on Tuesday's arguments in federal district court in Salt Lake City (UT) in an Establishment Clause challenge to markers placed on public property to memorialize state Highway Patrol officers. Since 1998, the Utah Highway Patrol Association has put up a 12-foot high cross near each place where a Highway Patrol officer died in the line of duty. Nine of the 13 crosses are on public property. Each carries the name of the officer being memorialized and the Utah Highway Patrol's insignia. Attorneys for American Atheists, Inc. argued that the crosses are religious symbols that should not be placed on government property. In response, the state asserted the crosses are secular symbols that memorialize deceased troopers and urge travellers to drive safely. (See prior related posting).
En Banc Review Sought In Indiana Legislative Prayer Case
According to today's Indianapolis Star, the ACLU of Indiana has petitioned the U.S. 7th Circuit Court of Appeals for en banc review of the decision in Hinrichs v. Speaker of the House of Representatives of the Indiana General Assembly, (7th Cir., Oct. 30, 2007). In October, a 3-judge panel, in a 2-1 decision, dismissed for lack of standing a suit brought by four Indiana taxpayers challenging the opening of sessions of the Indiana House of Representatives with Sectarian prayers. (See prior related posting.)
Enforcement of Illinois Moment of Silence Law Enjoined
An Illinois federal district court yesterday issued a preliminary injunction blocking a suburban Chicago school district from enforcing Illinois' new mandatory moment of silence law. (See prior related posting.) U.S. District Court Judge Robert Gettleman said the new law is vague and questioned how it is to be enforced. The Chicago Sun Times and AP report that the order came in a suit filed by radio talk-show host Rob Sherman, whose attorney has now asked the court to extend the injunction to all school district in the state.
UPDATE: Thursday's Arlington Heights (IL) Daily Herald reports that Judge Gettleman refused to extend his preliminary injunction to the state's other 214 school dstricts because they are not defendants in the case. However he did order the state school superintendent not to enforce the new law. This means that no sanctions will be imposed against other school districts that refuse to require a moment of silence.
UPDATE: The full opinion granting the preliminary injunction is now available on LEXIS: Sherman v. Township High School Dist. 214, 2007 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 84440 (ND IL, Nov. 15, 007).
UPDATE: Thursday's Arlington Heights (IL) Daily Herald reports that Judge Gettleman refused to extend his preliminary injunction to the state's other 214 school dstricts because they are not defendants in the case. However he did order the state school superintendent not to enforce the new law. This means that no sanctions will be imposed against other school districts that refuse to require a moment of silence.
UPDATE: The full opinion granting the preliminary injunction is now available on LEXIS: Sherman v. Township High School Dist. 214, 2007 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 84440 (ND IL, Nov. 15, 007).
Bishops Issue Guidance For Catholic Voters For 2008
Catholic News Service reports that the United State Conference of Catholic Bishops yesterday, by a vote of 221-4, approved a document intended to give guidance to Catholic voters in 2008. In addition to approving the document titled Forming Consciences for Faithful Citizenship: A Call to Political Responsibility From the Catholic Bishops of the United States, the bishops also approved a shorter parish bulletin insert on the topic by a vote of 221-1. Reporting on the Bishops' actions, today's New York Times quotes Bishop Nicholas DiMarzio who describes the document as offering: "a basic moral framework on what it means to be a Catholic and American, a believer and a voter in this coming election year." The document calls abortion an intrinsic evil that must always be opposed and rejected, but goes on to say: "There may be times when a Catholic who rejects a candidate’s unacceptable position may decide to vote for that candidate for other morally grave reasons."
Wednesday, November 14, 2007
Important Buddha Statue Attacked In Pakistan
Earlier this month, Islamic militants in Pakistan, for a second time, attacked a 40-meter tall Buddha carved in the rocks of northwestern Pakistan's Swat Valley. This attack destroyed the face, shoulder and feet of the important statue. Militants threaten another attack to completely destroy the sacred image. The government has not intervened to protect the site despite pleas by archaeologists. The attacks are similar to those in 2001 that destroyed another sacred Buddha statue in Bamiyan, Afghanistan. Reports on the Pakistan attacks have been carried by Asia News and the Daily Times of Pakistan.
Prayers For Rain Led By Georgia Governor On Statehouse Steps
CBS News reports on the hour-long event held on the grounds of Atlanta's state capitol yesterday in which Georgia Gov. Sonny Perdue led a crowd of several hundred people in prayer for rain for the drought-stricken state. Twenty members of the Atlanta Freethought Society, concerned about church-state separation, led a protest nearby. While the governor attempted to make the event an interfaith ceremony, only three Protestant clergy participated. CNN has a video clip of the Governor praying at the event. The AP says" While public prayer vigils might raise eyebrows in other parts of the nation, they are mostly shrugged off in the Bible Belt, where turning to the heavens for help is common and sometimes even politically expedient." (See prior related posting.)
Settlement Reached In Suit Between Tennessee Baptists and Belmont University
A settlement has been reached in the 2004 lawsuit brought by the Tennessee Baptist Convention against Belmont University, according to an ABP report yesterday. The litigation began after the school took steps to become independent. The Baptist Convention attempted to enforce a 1951 agreement that called for the school to reimburse the Convention for contributions if the school should "pass from Baptist control." Belmont University argued that the 1951 document had been superseded by later agreements. The settlement calls for Belmont to provide the Tennessee Baptist Convention with $11 million toward a missions and ministry endowment fund. A press release by Belmont University gives more details on the settlement which provides for a payout of funds to TBC over a 40-year period and
Prof. Harold Berman, Law and Religion Pioneer, Dies
Professor Harold J. Berman, a pioneer in the teaching of law and religion, died yesterday. The 89-year old professor taught for many years at Harvard Law School, and then moved to Emory Law School where he helped develop its law and religion program. Harvard Law School issued a release eulogizing Berman, whose expertise also extended to comparative, international, and Soviet law. Emory's website includes a bibliography of Berman's many books, articles and other writings. [Thanks to Patrick S. O'Donnell for the lead.]
Church-State Separation Proposed For Liechtenstein
Liechtenstein's Prime Minister Otmar Hasler is proposing an end to the special Constitutional designation of the Catholic Church as the country's national church. APD reported yesterday that the Prime Minister is calling for an institutional separation of church and state in Liechtenstein, with continued government support for church social service programs. In addition, taxpayers would be able to choose to allocate a portion of their income and property tax to one of the religious communities.
Trial Begins of Islamic Charity Leaders
In Boston yesterday, jury selection began in the criminal trial of three former leaders of Islamic charity, Care International Inc. The International Herald Tribune reports that the three are charged with tax code violations, making false statements and conspiracy to defraud the United States, stemming from allegedly false statements in the organization's application for 501(c)(3) tax exempt status. Prosecutors say the organization distributed a newsletter promoting jihad, but failed to tell the IRS that it supported mujahideen in various countries. (See prior related posting.)
Tuesday, November 13, 2007
Pope Will Visit U.S. In April
Yesterday Catholic News Service reported that Pope Benedict XVI will visit the United States in April 2008. He will be officially welcomed at the White House and will celebrate Mass at the new Washington Nationals baseball stadium. Also during his visit he will address the United Nations and visit ground zero in New York.
Churches Sue In Challenge To German Law Permitting Sunday Openings
In Germany, the Lutheran and Catholic Churches have filed suit to challenge the constitutionality of a new law that permits stores to remain open on ten Sundays each year, including the four Sundays before Christmas. AFP says that the two religious groups argue that workers have a constitutional right not to work on Sundays or holidays.
Payment for Confiscated Churches, End of State Support Proposed in Czech Republic
The government of the Czech Republic has agreed to propose a law to compensate churches in the country for property confiscated under Communist rule. Affecting mainly Catholic churches, the government will pay US$4.5 billion over a period of 70 years . Ekklesia today reports that the bill that will be introduced in December also contemplates churches becoming financially independent of the state. Direct payments to churches, including clergy salaries, will be gradually phased out over a ten-year period. While churches are happy with the proposal, the bill's fate in Parliament is uncertain as Social Democrats and former communists reflect public opinion against compensation. (See prior related posting.)
Challenge To Praying Parents Group In School Survives Summary Judgment Motion
In Doe v. Wilson County School System, 2007 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 83477 (MD TN, Nov. 9, 2007). a Tennessee federal district court refused to grant summary judgment to defendants, holding that genuine issues of material fact remain to be determined before the court can decide whether Lakeview Elementary School in Mt. Juliet, Tennessee, unconstitutionally endorsed religious activities and particular religious beliefs. At issue are activities in the school of a group known as Praying Parents. The lawsuit also raises questions about the school Principal's participation in the See You at the Pole National Day of Prayer event; a kindergarten Thanksgiving prayer; a school Christmas program; and playing of an inspirational CD in a class. (See prior related posting.)
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)