Defendants File Answers In Newdow Challenge To Inauguration Ceremony

Defendants yesterday filed responses in Newdow v. Roberts, (D DC), the pending federal district court challenge to two aspects of the upcoming Presidential Inauguration ceremony-- the planned prayers and the use of "so help me God" in the oath. (See prior posting.) One of the filings (full text) in opposition to the requested preliminary injunction was made on behalf of the federal officials who are defendants, while the second (full text) is on behalf of the Presidential Inauguration Committee (PIC). Both responses argue that plaintiffs lack standing. The federal defendants also set out extensive arguments on the merits while PIC and its executive director argue that PIC is not a governmental entity and so is not subject to constraints of the First Amendment or RFRA. In addition, CNN reported yesterday that an affidavit filed in the case confirms that Barack Obama has requested that the phrase "so help me God" be added to the constitutionally prescribed oath to be administered by the Chief Justice. [Thanks to Scott Mange for the lead.]

UPDATE: The Jan. 13 Legal Times recounts the experience of process server Daniel Portnoy in serving Chief Justice Roberts a summons in the case. The service at Roberts home went smoothly. Portnoy says the Chief Justice was "definitely a gentleman."

UPDATE2: Here is the amicus brief in the case filed on Jan. 14 by the American Center for Law and Justice in support of permitting inaugural prayer.

Tajikistan Supreme Court Bans Salafi Islam Movement

Radio Free Europe reported yesterday that the Supreme Court of Tajikistan has banned Salafi, a branch of the Sunni Islamic movement, from operating in the country. A Supreme Court spokesman said: "In order to prevent national, racial, and religious conflicts and damage to the nation's reputation and honor, Tajikistan's Supreme Court, as of January 8, 2009, bans the Salafi religious movement's activities in the country as an illegal group." Salafis do not recognise Shi'ites or Sufis. Some suspect that Western nations have funded the Salafis in Tajikistan because of the Salafis' anti-Iranian stance. Most Tajiks follow Hanafi, a more moderate branch of Sunni Islam than Salafi. The Institute for Religion and Public Policy issued a press release condemning the ban.

State AG's File Amicus Brief Opposing Newdow's Challenge To Inauguration Ceremony

Led by Texas Attorney General Greg Abbot (press release), the attorneys general of all 50 states and the Virgin Islands have filed an amicus brief (full text) in support of prayer and the use of "so help me God" in the oath at Barack Obama's upcoming inauguration. The suit on behalf of 40 individuals and organizations, including activist Michael Newdow, was filed last week in federal district court in the District of Columbia. (See prior posting.) A hearing is scheduled for next week. (See prior posting.) The brief argues:

Prayers and oaths invoking God have been incorporated into public inaugural ceremonies throughout our Nation's history and at every level of government. Plaintiffs have not presented a single legal precedent holding unconstitutional such historical customs and practices.

It also cites authority in 26 states incorporating the phrase "so help me God" (or similar phrase) into oaths of office for state officials.

American Jewish Congress Hit Hard By Madoff Fraud

One of the nation's most important voices on church-state issues, the American Jewish Congress, has been hard hit by the Bernard Madoff fraud according to a report yesterday by the Forward. Some $21 million of the organization's $24 million endowment was invested with Madoff. Endowment funds accounted for about 25% of AJCongress' annual budget of $6.2 million. Marc Stern, the organization's acting co-executive director, called the losses "a serious blow", but "not fatal." One of the first cuts is likely to be the group's monthly magazine, Congress Monthly. (See prior related posting.)

Richard John Neuhaus, Leading Catholic Thinker, Dies

New York Catholic priest, Richard John Neuhaus, died yesterday at the age of 72. The National Catholic Reporter says that Neuhaus was known as an intellectual spokesman for the "religious right." Originally ordained as a Lutheran minister, Neuhaus converted to Catholicism in 1990. According to NCR:

From the early 1970s forward, Neuhaus was a key architect of two alliances with profound consequences for American politics, both of which overcame histories of mutual antagonism: one between conservative Catholics and Protestant Evangelicals, and the other between free market neo-conservatives and “faith and values” social conservatives.

Among the books written by Fr. Neuhaus were The Naked Public Square: Religion and Democracy in America (1997); Appointment in Rome: The Church in America Awakening (1998); and Doing Well & Doing Good: The Challenge to the Christian Capitalist (1992).

Mississippi Bill Would Require Disclaimer Stickers In Biology Textbooks

As state legislatures reconvene, anti-evolution bills again begin to be introduced. On Tuesday, Mississippi state representative Gary Chism introduced into Mississippi's legislature HB 25 (full text), a bill that would require the State Board of Education to place stickers with disclaimers in every textbook that includes material on evolution. The lengthy required disclaimer includes the statement: "No one was present when life first appeared on earth. Therefore, any statement about life's origins should be considered a theory." The disclaimer ends with the admonition: "Study hard and keep an open mind." [Thanks to Tony's Curricublog via Scott Mange.]

Kerala India Commission To Propose Several Religious Reforms

In India, the Law Reforms Commission of the state of Kerala is scheduled to issue a controversial report to the government on January 24. India Today and IANS this week preview recommendations that will impact Muslims, Catholics and Hindus. The Commission, headed by former Supreme Court Judge V.R. Krishna Iyer, will recommend a ban on the Muslim practice polygamy, except in extraordinary circumstances and only with permission of the first wife. The report will urge that all assets of Catholic churches be held in public trusts of individual dioceses. And the report will urge that non-Brahmins be eligible for appointment as Hindu priests.

Settlement Bars Louisiana From Making Unrestricted Grants To Churches

AP reported yesterday that the state of Louisiana has agreed to settle a lawsuit brought against it by the ACLU challenging appropriations in the 2007 state budget bill for two churches, with no restrictions on the churches' use of the funds. (Similar appropriations to six other churches had also been approved.) In August 2007, a federal district court issued a preliminary injunction barring the state from disbursing the appropriated funds. (See prior posting.) Under the agreed-upon settlement, the state will no longer grant unrestricted funds to churches.

Christian Groups Seek To Ban Imposition of Fairness Doctrine On Broadcasters

The Christian Coalition of America has begun an online petition campaign to prevent the FCC under Democratic leadership from again imposing the "Fairness Doctrine" on radio broadcasters. (Press release(Jan. 8)). The group argues that a return of the requirement that equal time be given on the air to opposing views on controversial issues would have the effect of ending conservative talk radio shows such as those of Rush Limbaugh, Sean Hannity and Bill O'Reilly. A CBN report yesterday says: "Some Republicans feel that at a time when Christianity has become controversial, a revived Fairness Doctrine could be used to press Christian stations to air anti-Christian views." Three bills have already been introduced in the new Congress to prohibit the FCC from reinstating the fairness requirement: S. 34, S. 62 and H.R. 226.

New Bangladesh Prime Minister Wants Return To Secularism

Bangladesh's new Prime Minister, Sheikh Hasina, says that she will move to restore the country's first constitution, framed in 1972, in order to return the country to the principle of secularism. LiveMint.com reported yesterday that since a 1975 coup, Bangladesh has experienced a rise in religious militancy as religion-based parties entered politics. IANS yesterday quotes Law, Justice and Parliamentary Affairs Minister Shafique Ahmed who also says that the government will restore the basic principles of the 1972 Constitution which focused on the principles of nationalism, democracy, secularism and socialism. Ahmed says he seeks a return of democracy, human rights and the rule of law.

Title VII Claim Against Orthodox Jewish Organization Dismissed

In Wechsler v. Orthodox Union, 2008 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 105780 (SD NY, Jan. 5, 2009), a New York federal district court dismissed a Title VII religious discrimination and retaliation complaint brought against the Orthodox Union. The court held that Section 702 of the 1964 Civil Rights Act (42 USC Sec. 2000e-1) exempts religious organizations from religious discrimination claims under the Act. The Orthodox Union is an Orthodox Jewish organization that, among other things, operates a kosher certification agency. Plaintiff was employed by the OU as a mashgiach (kosher inspector) at a New York restaurant and apparently was fired based on his religious observance. The court rejected plaintiff's argument that applying the exemption in Sec. 702 to this case would violate the Establishment Clause and held that the OU's denial of religious discrimination does not take the case out of the exemption.

AU Protests School's Fellowship of Christian Athletes Room

Americans United yesterday sent a letter (full text) to Hot Springs, Arkansas school officials protesting the recent construction of a special meeting room for the Fellowship of Christian Athletes as an addition to Fountain Lake High School's football complex. According to an AU press release, the room was paid for by private funds, but its construction was the idea of school officials. Supporting the room, Assistant Coach Andi Kinsinger said: "This new building will make a statement and hopefully change the lives of many for His Glory.... FCA camp is where I came to know Christ; it provides a lot of opportunity for all." AU says the room amounts to an unconstitutional endorsement of religion. It has asked the school to remove from the room a plaque that displays a crucifix and reads "Fellowship of Christian Athletes meets Here!"; to stop referring to the room as the "FCA room"; and to permit other groups equal access to it.

Protest Against Court Decision on License Plates Includes State Officials

In Greer, South Carolina on Tuesday, the state's attorney general and lieutenant governor joined some 400 others at People's Baptist Church to protest a decision handed down by a federal district court last month preliminarily enjoining production of the state's proposed "I Believe" license plates. The plate also featured a Christian cross. (See prior posting.) Yesterday's Spartanburg Herald-Journal reported that Rev. Arnold Hiette told Tuesday's crowd that the plaintiffs in the case, along with the ACLU, "are going to burn in hell." Lt. Governor Andre Bauer also spoke at the event, which took the form of a prayer meeting, saying: "There is free speech for every group in this state besides Christians.... I don't understand why witnessing in public is considered unconstitutional."

1st Amendment Suit Against Ohio Library Settled For Attorneys' Fees

Yesterday's Cincinnati Enquirer reports that a lawsuit against the Clermont County (OH) Public Library, challenging its rules on use of its meeting rooms, has been settled. Under previous library rules, rooms could be used by non-profit community groups, but not for political, religious or social events. The suit, alleging 1st and 14th Amendment violations, was brought by a couple who wanted to present two days of Biblically-based financial planning workshops. In response the library changed its rules to exclude all outside groups from using the rooms. (See prior posting.) Under the settlement, plaintiffs' attorneys receive $10,000 in fees. Plaintiff George Vandergriff expressed disappointment that the settlement did not include an admission of wrongdoing by the library. However Joe Braun, president of the library board, said: "Every member of the Clermont County Library Board is a practicing Christian. So it’s beyond my comprehension that anyone would suggest we would treat someone in an improper manner because of their religion."

Lawyers In RLUIPA Case Spar Over "Daily Show" Clip As Evidence

As previously reported, a lawsuit under RLUIPA against Fayette County, Pennsylvania, brought by the Church of Universal Love and Music, is pending in federal district court. The church is seeking rezoning or a special exception so it can continue to use property in an agricultural area for religious concerts. County officials claim that concert venue founder William Pritts did not claim that his organization was a church until zoning problems arose. AP reported on Tuesday that the county wants to introduce into evidence a 2003 comedy segment from the Daily Show featuring Pritts to show that Pritts is not sincere in his claim that the organization is a church. The four-minute segment (video) includes Pritts saying "God never said you can't party on." Pritts' attorneys have filed a motion to exclude the evidence, saying that it is not relevant and that the segment was heavily edited by the show's producers. [Thanks to Brian D. Wassom for the lead.]

UPDATE: On January 22, the court ruled the jury will not be able to view the video clip, but that the court might reach a different conclusion if an unedited version of the entire interview (without a laugh track) were to become available. (Uniontown (PA) Herald Standard, 1/24/09).

Canadian Arrests Are Likely Challenge To Canada's Polygamy Laws

Yesterday Canadian authorities arrested two religious leaders in Bountiful, British Columbia on charges of polygamy. AP and the Salt Lake Tribune report on the arrest of Jim Oler, bishop of the town's FLDS community and Winston Blackmore, bishop of a competing polygamous group in the town. Blackmore was expelled from the FLDS church in 2002. Oler is charged with having two wives, while Blackmore is charged with having 20 wives. The National Post says the cases, which do not involve underage wives, is likely to be a test of the constitutionality of Canada's ban on polygamy. British Columbia's Attorneys General have feared that the laws will not survive a challenge under the religious freedom guarantee of Canada's Charter of Rights and Freedoms. (See prior posting.)

New Orleans Police Evict Protesters From Closed Catholic Churches

The New Orleans Times-Picayune reports on yesterday's police eviction of protesters from two New Orleans Catholic churches that had been closed by the Archdiocese. Police were accompanied by lawyers from the city attorney's office and by members of the Archdiocese property management office who supervised changing of locks on the churches. Parishioners had occupied the churches for over ten weeks to protest their closure. The Archdiocese said it requested police assistance at Our Lady of Good Counsel and at St. Henry Church after protesters locked themselves in the buildings. The controversy began when Archbishop Alfred Hughes last April ordered 142 parishes reduced to 108.

Vietnam Issues New Directive On Land For Religious Uses

Vietnam's Prime Minister Nguyen Tan Dung has issued a new Directive to assure uniform land management approaches to allocation of land for religious uses. Vietnam News Agency reports today that Directive 1940/CT-TTg calls for government units to speed up the granting of land use certificates to religious organizations that meet legal requirements. It calls for the government and the Communist Party to respect organizations' right to practice their religion. However, Dung warned churches against using the land issue to incite public disorder or undermine national unity. Radio Australia points out that the new directive comes in the wake of a series of recent property disputes between Vietnamese Catholics and the state. (See prior posting.)

Federal Lawsuit By Amish Challenges Building Code Enforcement

The Becket Fund announced yesterday that it had filed suit in a New York federal district court on behalf of eleven Amish families challenging enforcement of Morristown, NY's building code provisions that infringe plaintiffs' religious beliefs. The complaint (full text) in Yoder v. Town of Morristown, (ND NY, filed 1/6/2009), alleges that he religious beliefs of the Swartzentruber Amish preclude them from submitting architect-stamped construction plans, from installing battery-powered smoke detectors, from equipping their houses with hurricane tie-downs and from frost protecting their homes' foundations. The complaint alleges that denying building permits to plaintiffs violates their free exercise, speech, assembly and equal protection rights under the U.S. and New York constitutions, as well as the federal Fair Housing Act and RLUIPA. Plaintiffs trace their problems to the actions of a new Code Enforcement Officer appointed in 2006, saying that prior to that they lived for many years in "peaceful co-existence" with the non-Amish Morristown residents. Yesterday's Watertown (NY) Daily Times reports on the filing of the case.

UPDATE: On Friday, a New York state trial judge ruled that two Amish families in Hammond (NY) can remain in their homes that were constructed without building permits while the federal challenge against Morristown is pending. The judge also ruled, however, that the town of Hammond cannot be liable for any death or injury involving the two families. (Watertown Daily Times, Jan. 10; WNYTV News, Jan. 9).

First 2009 Foray At Evolution Teaching Introduced In Oklahoma

The National Center for Science Education reports that the first anti-evolution bill to be introduced in a legislature in 2009 is Oklahoma's proposed Scientific Education and Academic Freedom Act (SB 320). The NCSE posting also sets out the full text of the bill which provides in part:

educational authorities in this state shall ... endeavor to assist teachers to find more effective ways to present the science curriculum where it addresses scientific controversies. Toward this end, teachers shall be permitted to help students understand, analyze, critique, and review in an objective manner the scientific strengths and scientific weaknesses of existing scientific theories pertinent to the course being taught....

It also provides that:

Students may be evaluated based upon their understanding of course materials, but no student in any public school or institution shall be penalized in any way because the student may subscribe to a particular position on scientific theories.

This act only protects the teaching of scientific information, and this act shall not be construed to promote any religious or non-religious doctrine, promote discrimination for or against a particular set of religious beliefs or non-beliefs, or promote discrimination for or against religion or non-religion.