Splits within Protestant denominations on the ordination of gay clergy are now finding their way into civil courts. In Ridgebury, New York, a small Presbyterian congregation is breaking away from the Presbyterian Church (USA) in protest of the denomination's willingness to ordain gays. The Church at Ridgebury however is trying to keep its church building and property in the process. The White Plains Journal News reported earlier this month that the church's regional body is now suing, claiming that under church rules (the Book of Order) all church property is held in trust for the denomination.
Similar disputes are racking the Episcopal Church. Last month (see prior posting), a breakaway Episcopal congregation in California was permitted to keep its church property as it broke away from the parent body in protest over its teachings on homosexuality. Now, according to an Associated Press report yesterday, a more far-ranging federal lawsuit has been filed in Connecticut. In it, six Episcopal parishes at the center of a dispute over gay clergy allege that their civil rights have been violated by Connecticut's bishop, the head of the U.S. Episcopal Church and others.
The priests of the six parishes that filed the lawsuit had asked to be supervised by a different bishop because they disagreed with their bishop's support for the ordination of the Episcopal Church's first openly gay bishop. Interestingly, the lawsuit also names Connecticut Attorney General Richard Blumenthal as a defendant. The suit claims that the state has entangled itself in the religious dispute because state law requires Episcopal parishes to operate under the rules of the Connecticut diocese. The full text of the 67-page complaint in the lawsuit is available online. It asks for an injunction to prevent the parent church from interfering with the dissident parishes, an ejectment order, a declaration that various state statutes relating to the Episcopal Church are unconstitutional, and damages.
