The Honolulu Star Bulletin reported yesterday three West Hawaii cultural and community groups are angry that they were not consulted when a residential and golf development at Kohanaiki, North Kona, found old Hawaiian wooden images in a lava tube cave last month. The three groups are the Kohanaiki Ohana, Pono I Ke Kanawai and Na Keiki Hee Nalu O Hawaii. They are threatening legal action.
More than 20 images, believed to be kii, or carved images of gods, were found. Probably dating from the first half of the 19th century, the objects might be religious images hidden when the old Hawaiian religion was overthrown. Or they might be commercial objects created for sale to foreign sailors, said Hawaiian historian Herb Kane. No human bones were found in the lava tube, said the development's archaeological consultant, Paul Rosendahl. He said, since this is not a burial site and the objects were accidentally discovered, the landowner has legal right to determine how to dispose of the artifacts. The three groups responded, "Gods do not belong to individuals; they belong to the community whose values and practices they represent. They are the cultural and intellectual property of a social group." Rosendahl said the developers are not obliged to turn the images over to any particular group that makes a claim. The developers are working with "those with the strongest genealogical and residential ties."
