The Des Moines Register reports on closing arguments that were presented Friday by lawyers in federal district court in Iowa in a case challenging InnerChange, a faith-based prison treatment program. Operating in Iowa and elsewhere, inmates in the program immerse themselves in Christian values. (See prior related postings 1, 2.) Americans United for the Separation of Church and State has sued Iowa prison officials and Prison Fellowship Ministries, which operates the program, claiming that InnerChange violates the Establishment Clause. The suit seeks repayment of $1.5 million in state funds that have been used for InnerChange.
Lawyers for Americans United argue that the program "requires and coerces inmates to take part in religious activities." They say it discriminates against other religious beliefs, particularly Catholicism, and provides special privileges to participants. These include an opportunity to complete treatment classes required for parole earlier than they could otherwise. Defense lawyers dispute these claims, saying no one is forced to participate and that participants receive no preference for paroles. "Inmates of all faiths and no faiths are welcome," said Anthony Troy, a lawyer for Prison Fellowship. He says that those of other faiths who join the program can continue to observe their traditions
