Competing Opinions On Constitutionality Of Utah's Proposed Voucher System

The Salt Lake Tribune reports that on Wednesday, the Utah School Boards Association released two legal opinions that say H.B. 184, a school voucher bill before the Legislature, is unconstitutional. Former Utah Supreme Court Justice Michael D. Zimmerman said HB184 violates prohibitions in Utah's constitution against using public funds for religious education (Art. I, Sec. 4, Art. X, Sec. 9). A second opinion, by attorney Harold G. Christensen, says that the voucher bill violates Utah's constitutional provisions providing for the creation of a public education system (Art. X, Sec. 1). Parents for Choice in Education disagrees, citing a legal opinion by attorney Maxwell A. Miller taking the position that the Utah constitution supports indirect funding for private education.