Court Upholds Student's Dismissal For Suggesting Church

The decision has just become available in Watts v. Florida International University, 2005 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 40310 (SD Fla., June 9, 2005). The case, decided by a Florida federal judge some 8 months ago, involved John Watts, a state university student, who was terminated from a Master of Social Work program "for inappropriate behavior related to patients, involving religion". Watts recommended to a patient that she seek a bereavement support group. When the patient inquired where she could find such a group, Mr. Watts provided several options, one of which was "church," because the patient's assessment indicated that she was Catholic. The mention of a religious alternative was apparently the offending behavior. The court held that dismissing the student for giving this advice did not violate either his right to free speech or to the free exercise of religion. Watts did not show how preventing him from providing the information to the patient constituted a substantial burden on the exercise of his central religious beliefs.