The Toronto Star reported yesterday that the Ontario legislature has now formally passed legislation to prohibit the use of religious tribunals to decide divorce, custody and other family law disputes. Premier Dalton McGuinty originally focused on prohibiting the use of Shariah (Muslim law) to decide family law cases. There was widespread concern that panels applying Shariah would discriminate against women in their rulings. But the legislation that McGuinty introduced, and which now has passed, prohibits all religious arbitrations in Ontario. Bill 27-2006 provides that an arbitration in family law matters that is not conducted exclusively in accordance with the law of Ontario or of another Canadian jurisdiction, the decision has no legal effect. The new law is an amendment to the Ontario Arbitration Act of 1991 that generally provides for judicial enforcement of arbitration awards.
The Canadian Jewish News says that the impact of the new law on Jewish rabbinical courts (Bet Dins) is not completely clear. Apparently it will not impact their ability to issue a get in divorce actions. However, the absence of transitional provisions will call into question previous family law rulings of rabbinical courts that have not yet been incorporated into civil court decrees.
