Monday, February 13, 2006

Science Education In Ohio Under Examination

In Columbus tomorrow, Ohio's State Board of Education is expected to again discuss Ohio's science standards and model lesson plan that call for critical analysis of evolution, as concern over the constitutionality of Ohio's approach continues. (Akron Beacon Journal.) (See prior related postings 1, 2 .) The Discovery Institute, a supporter of the theory of Intelligent Design, today released a Zogby poll that it commissioned in Ohio. The poll concluded that 68.8% of respondents want scientific evidence against evolution taught along with evolutionary theory.

Today's Toledo Blade ran an article on what is actually happening in Ohio classrooms. It suggests that some of those teaching intelligent design may have aberrational views about other aspects of science as well:

Michael Maveal wants his eighth-grade students at Jones Junior High to know the truth - as he sees it. So, the Toledo Public Schools science teacher tells them that evolution is an unproven theory, as is creation. He teaches them about Nebraska man, a creature rejected by science long ago, to demonstrate the fallibility of evolution. He teaches them that Pluto has never been seen. (It has.) He teaches them that humans are not animals. (We are.) He teaches them about the famous scientific hoax, Piltdown man, once purported to be an early human ancestor.

"I'm not afraid of dealing with all the fakery that's going on in all the science community,'' Mr. Maveal said. "We have to present information to the kids so they can make an intelligent decision for themselves. "I tell them what the scientists won't admit."

While Mr. Maveal is unusual in his willingness to acknowledge his disbelief in evolution, and his highly skeptical treatment of generally accepted science, his approach reveals the turmoil that exists in some science classrooms.