Saturday, July 08, 2006

Justice Kennedy Stays Order To Remove Mt. Soledad Cross

The battle to preserve the Mt. Soledad Cross took on new life yesterday. U.S. Supreme Court Justice Anthony Kennedy issued an in-chambers opinion granting a stay of the federal district court's order to remove the cross pending final disposition of the appeal to the Ninth Circuit. (See prior posting.) The Ninth Circuit had denied a stay of the district court order to remove the cross, though it had ordered expedited briefing and scheduled argument for Oct. 16, 2006. Earlier this week Kennedy issued a temporary stay. Now in San Diegans for the Mt. Soledad National War Memorial v. Paulson, (Sup. Ct., July 7, 2006), Kennedy, sitting as Circuit Justice, wrote:
[T]he equities here support preserving the status quo while the city's appeal proceeds. Compared to the irreparable harm of altering the memorial and removing the cross, the harm in a brief delay ... seems slight. In addition, two further factors make this case "sufficiently unusual" ... to warrant granting a stay. First, a recent Act of Congress has deemed the monument a "national memorial honoring veterans of the United States Armed Forces" and has authorized the Secretary of the Interior to take title to the memorial on behalf of the United State if the city offers to donate it. Sec.116, 118 Stat. 3346.... Second, San Diego voters, seeking to carry out the transfer ... have approved a ballot proposition authorizing donation of the monument to the United States. While the Superior Court ... has invalidated the ballot proposition [on state constitutional grounds,] ... if the state appellate court reverses ... and allows the memorial to become federal property, its decision may moot the District Court's injunction, which addresses only the legality under state law of the cross' presence on city property....
Today's San Diego Union-Tribune has a story on Justice Kennedy's decision.
[Thanks to SCOTUS Blog for the link.]