Navajo-Hopi Dispute Over Sacred Lands Continues

Over the last week, three stories in the Gallup (NM) Independent traced the most recent development in the decades-old Navajo-Hopi land dispute. See newspaper's articles at 1, 2, 3 . Since 1958, the Hopi Tribe and the Navajo Nation have been involved in litigation over ownership of 3.5 million acres of land in Arizona. Both tribes want access to the disputed land for religious ceremonies. In 1974, Congress authorized a compact to settle the major lawsuit. Over the last four years, Navajo and Hopi negotiating teams have reached agreement on language for the proposed compact. The compact must be approved by both tribal councils, by U.S. District Court Judge Earl Carroll and by the Secretary of the Interior. Under the proposed settlement, the Navajos retain ownership of the disputed land and both tribes will maintain access to the other's land for religious ceremonies. However, last Monday the Government Services Committee of the Navajo Nation Council voted 3-2 against the proposed settlement. A few members of the Navajo nation have filed suit seeking an injunction against the approval of the compromise, claiming it was negotiated in secret. Portions of the compact that identify the precise location of sacred Hopi sites are to remain confidential, available only to tribal officials with responsibility for enforcing the compact.