Church May Be Liable For Negligent Supervision Of Minister-Marriage Counselor

Here is a case from a few months ago that has not previously been noted. In Vione v. Tewell, (Sup. Ct. NY County, May 19, 2006), a New York trial court held that it would not unconstitutionally impinge on ecclesiastical issues if it moved forward with plaintiff's claims that a minister was having an affair with his wife at the same time he was providing secular marriage counseling to the couple. The court said that a claim had been stated for breach of fiduciary duty by the minister acting as marriage counselor, but that the church was not vicariously liable because the minister was acting outside the scope of his duties in having sexual relation with plaintiff's wife. However the church could be liable for negligent retention and supervision of the minister.