Largely echoing the reasoning in his denial of a preliminary injunction, a Georgia federal district judge has upheld the practices of the Cobb County (GA) Commission in opening its sessions with prayer. In Pelphrey v. Cobb County, Georgia, Civil Action No. 1:05-CV-2075-RWS (ND GA, Sept. 8, 2006) [available through PACER], the court held that legislative prayer violates the Establishment Clause only if there is an impermissible motive in the selection of clergy; use of invocations to promote the beliefs of one religious sect or to disparage the beliefs of another; or maintenance of a practice that conveys governmental preference of one religious view over others. The court found that neither the identity of those offering invocations, nor the sometimes sectarian references in their prayers, were sufficient to violate the Establishment Clause. The court similarly upheld the selection procedures used by Cobb County in locating individuals to deliver invocations, even though it resulted in 96% of those delivering invocations being Christian.
However in a parallel challenge to the invocation policy of the Cobb County Planning Commission, the court found that its policies in 2003-04 for selecting individuals to deliver invocations did violate the Establishment Clause. "[C]ertain faiths were categorically excluded from the list of prospective speakers based on the content of their faith."
Today’s Atlanta Journal Constitution discusses the decision.
UPDATE: The opinion is now available on LEXIS at 2006 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 64294 (ND GA, Sept. 8, 2006),
