House Passes Ban on Attorneys' Fees In Establishment Clause Cases

Earlier today, the U.S. House of Representatives passed H.R. 2679. The bill, originally known as, the Public Expression of Religion Act, (see prior posting) was amended prior to passage to be called the "Veterans' Memorials, Boy Scouts, Public Seals, and Other Public Expressions of Religion Protection Act of 2006". The bill passed by a vote of 244-173. The House vote and background is reported by ABP News. Here is a listing of the vote cast by each House member. The controversial bill would prevent federal courts from awarding attorneys' fees to plaintiffs in suits alleging Establishment Clause violations by state or local governments, and would limit relief to injunctions and declaratory judgments. A number of religious and civil liberties groups opposed the bill, arguing that it will chill the ability of minority groups to defend their religious liberties. However, proponents say that the threat of attorneys' fee awards gives plaintiffs undue leverage in negotiating settlements of Establishment Clause claims. The measure is not likely to become law because, according to ABP, it is unlikely that the Senate will vote on the companion bill pending in that chamber before the current session of Congress ends.