Navy Chaplains Lose Evidentiary Challenge

Plaintiffs have suffered a loss in a long-running challenge to the Navy Chaplain Corps' hiring, promotion and retention policies. Adair v. Winter, 2006 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 64327 (DDC, Sept. 11, 2006), involves issues at the discovery stage of the case that was brought by current and former Navy chaplains and an agency that certifies chaplains. Plaintiffs claim that Naval policy favors liturgical Christian sects over non-liturgical Christian sects. This opinion involves a constitutional challenge to 10 USC 618(f) that denies plaintiffs civil discovery of the proceedings of Naval officer promotion boards. The court held that there is no constitutional right to privileged evidence in the case, and that the board proceedings are not essential to plaintiffs' proving their claim. (See prior related posting.)