School's Motion To Dismiss Suit On "Day of Truth" Cards Dismissed

Last week in Arthurs v. Sampson County Board of Education, (ED NC, Oct. 2, 2006), a North Carolina federal district court refused to dismiss a lawsuit against a North Carolina school system brought by a Christian student who was not permitted to hand out Day of Truth cards presenting a Christian view on homosexuality. (See prior posting.) The Sampson County Board of Education had moved to dismiss on the ground that the student's speech was not religious speech, but the court disagreed. In a press release, the Alliance Defense Fund, representing the student, said: "It’s clearly unconstitutional when students participating in the Day of Silence, which supports the homosexual agenda, are permitted to observe their event by distributing flyers ..., but a student with an opposite perspective is prevented from communicating it during non-instructional time."