The U.S. 5th Circuit Court of Appeals on Friday issued an important decision on the opening of school board meetings with sectarian prayer. In Doe v. Tangipahoa Parish School Board, (5th Cir., Dec. 15, 2005), the court, in three divergent opinions, affirmed in part and vacated in part an injunction against opening school board meetings with religious invocations that had been issued by the district court in 2005. The district court, in its opinion, had held that the proper test to be applied was the Supreme Court's three-part Lemon test, rather than the legislative prayer exception of Marsh v. Chambers.
In the 5th Circuit, only Judge Stewart agreed fully with the district court. Judge Clement's opinion said that Marsh rather than Lemon applies to school board invocations, and found that all of the challenged prayers were permissible under Marsh. None of them "exploited the prayer opportunity either 'to proselytize or advance any one, or to disparage any other, faith or belief'." Judge Barksdale assumed, without deciding, that Marsh applied, but found that the prayers at issue were overtly sectarian, and were therefore not permitted by Marsh. The result of these splintered opinions was that the trial court's injunction was affirmed as to four specific prayers, but vacated insofar as it more broadly prohibited all prayer at board meetings.
The decision was covered by today's New Orleans Times-Picayune.
