Sunday's Arizona Daily Star chronicles a convoluted and unusual legal issue that has surfaced as two factions fight for control of the Universal Life Church Monestary and its assets. Through its website, the Monestary offers instant and free ordination as a minister. It claims to have ordained over 20 million individuals. Now, however, the bona fides of some of those ordinations are in question because the website has been run since August 1 by George Freeman, who is not legally an officer of the church.
The church's true CEO, Daniel Zimmerman, claims control of the church and its website has been improperly taken by Freeman (who once ran a Seattle church known by some as a nightclub where teens could find group sex and drugs). In February, Freeman filed papers with the Arizona Corporation Commission stating that the non-profit corporation's board of directors voted to remove Zimmerman as CEO because he engaged in "fraudulent conduct," conducted himself in a manner unbecoming a board member, and because of a recent arrest. Subsequently the Corporation Commission decided that Freeman's documents were "accepted in error" and they were returned to him. This means that Zimmerman is recognized as CEO as a matter of legal record.
Online requests for ordination after Aug. 1, however, were processed by Freeman. Since he is no longer recognized by the Arizona Corporation Commission as an officer of the church, these ministers may not have been legally ordained. That apparently places the validity of some of the marriages they performed in doubt. Zimmerman says it also places "the baptism of countless babies is at risk", although it is not exactly clear what that means.
Of course, it may be that the heart of the dispute here is the church's real estate, its $129,000 in cash, and the value of sales of ministerial supplies and materials it offers through its website (allegedly worth $15 million). Zimmerman is apparently willing to give up legal control of the church if he gets a retirement package worth several hundred thousand dollars that he says was promised to him.
