Friday, December 22, 2006

Controversy Continues Around Government-Sponsored Holiday Displays

As Christmas draws near, here is a roundup from around the world of stories from the past two days on governmentally sponsored holiday displays:

NZZ Online reports that in Switzerland a debate has been raging on whether Christmas celebrations in public schools should be banned out of concern for the feelings of Muslims. The debate originated when comments made by the president of the Swiss teachers' association were misconstrued. IN response, Muslim organizations have specifically requested that Christmas celebrations be kept in the schools.

In Olympia, Washington, officials have rejected a request by a resident that a nativity scene be placed beside the Menorah at the capitol building. The Associated Press reports that even though the Menorah was lit by the governor, officials believe that the nativity scene would be a stronger governmental endorsement of religion. However, in Wailuku, Hawaii, Maui County officials have installed a Christmas tree next to a Hanukkah menorah and dreidel already on display at the county building. The Honolulu Advertiser reports that the step was taken after the ACLU objected that the Hanukkah display alone could give the impression that the county was endorsing Judaism.

UPDATE: On Dec. 27, the Alliance Defense Fund announced that it had filed a complaint seeking a temporary restraining order in Washington state to permit a nativity scene to be displayed in the state capitol rotunda on the same terms as the menorah and holiday tree that are already there.

In a Toronto, Ontario courthouse, a Christmas tree that was originally moved to a back lobby on the orders of one of the judges (see prior posting) has reappeared in its original place in the courthouse's main foyer. The Toronto Star reports that after the province's attorney general spoke with the chief justice, the earlier directive was reversed. Officials also agreed that in January they would discuss creating a formal policy on holiday decorations. Attorney General Michael Bryant, apparently suggesting that the incident had been overblown, said: "We don't see the need to bring a habeas corpus application to free the tree just yet. Amnesty International has not called to date."