Court Rejects Amish Objections To Septic Tank Requirements

In Beechy v. Central Michigan District Health Department, 2007 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 15157 (ED MI, Feb. 20, 2007), a Michigan federal district court rejected a free exercise challenge by members of the Old Order Amish faith to a health ordinance prescribing the capacity of a septic tank that must be installed on their residential property. The court found that plaintiffs merely claim that their religious beliefs and practices lead to their not generating enough waste water to require the 750 gallon tank required by law. They do not claim that installing the larger tank actually interferes with their religious beliefs or practices. So their objection to the larger tank are based on secular concerns of cost, convenience and lack of need.