Challenge To Closing of NY Catholic Church Rejected

In Church of Our Lady of Vilna v. Archbishopric of New York, (NY Sup. Ct., May 29, 2007), a New York trial court rejected a challenge to a decision by the Archdiocese of New York to close a church that originally served the Lithuanian immigrant community because of declining attendance. The court held that plaintiffs lacked standing to challenge the closing because the rector and the two plaintiffs who claimed to be board members of the Church had been replaced. That replacement, carried out by hierarchical church authorities, was an ecclesiastical decision beyond the power of civil courts to review. The court similarly rejected a challenge to the removal of church property by the new rector because church bylaws give the rector and the Archbishop control over the property.