9th Circuit Holds Segregated Inmates Must Still Get Access To Religious Services

In Pierce v. County of Orange, (9th Cir., March 24, 2008), the U.S. 9th Circuit Court of Appeals ruled that Orange County (CA) jails are systematically denying inmates in administrative segregation access to religious services in violation of their First Amendment rights. It held that"a detainee’s placement in administrative segregation does not, standing alone, justify a complete denial of opportunities to practice religion." The court found that a previously issued injunction requiring that inmates in administrative segregation be given once-per-week access to scheduled religious services, a chapel visit or a meeting with a religious adviser should continue to be enforced. The holding was part of a lengthy opinion in a class action lawsuit that also challenged other jail conditions. Reporting on the decision yesterday, the Orange County Register said that most of the jail inmates in administrative segregation are those charged with sex crimes.