IL Appellate Court Majority Invalidates Ban On Heirs Intermarrying

In In re Estate of Max Feinberg, (IL Ct. App., June 30, 2008), an Illinois District Court of Appeals, in a 2-1 decision, held unenforceable decedents' testamentary provision disinheriting any grandchild who marries outside the Jewish faith unless the spouse converts within one year of the marriage. Justice Cunningham delivering the opinion of the court held that public policy invalidates such provisions because they seriously interfere with an individual's right to marry the person of his or her choice. The opinion cites Restatement Third of Trusts that takes this position as well. Justice Quinn concurred specially, in order to more specifically counter the arguments of the dissent. Justice Greiman dissented, pointing out that a majority of other jurisdictions validate such provisions. He characterized the clause as an attempt by Max and Erla Feinberg to "to preserve their 4,000 year old heritage." An op-ed in yesterday's St. Louis Jewish Light discusses decision.