Title VII's Religious Organization Exclusion Held Non-Jurisdictional

Smith v. Angel Food Ministries, Inc., 2008 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 98280 (MD GA, Dec. 4 2008) is a religious discrimination decision that will be of interest to experts in the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure. Angel Food Ministries (AFM) is an organization that partners with churches to help distribute food to the poor. James and Crystal Smith, who were employed by AFM in non-clergy positions, were discharged because they had stopped attending Emmanuel Praise Church. Attendance was a condition of employment. When the Smiths sued under Title VII of the 1964 Civil Rights Act claiming religious discrimination, AFM moved to dismiss for lack of subject matter jurisdiction, arguing that AFM comes within the exclusion in Title VII (Sec. 702) that permits religious organizations to hire on the basis of religion. The Smiths contend that AFM is not a religious organization entitled to claim that exemption. The court held that whether the religious exemption is available is not a "jurisdictional" question. Therefore plaintiffs' FRCP Rule 12(b)(1) motion is not the appropriate way to assert the defense. Instead the defense should be raised, after discovery, by way of a Rule 12(b)(6) motion for failure to state a claim, or a Rule 56 motion for summary judgment.