Court Rejects Street Preacher's Suit Against Police

In Decker v. City of Athens, 2009 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 55348 (ED TN, June 29, 2009), a Tennessee federal district court dismissed a street preacher's 1st Amendment claims against the city of Athens, Tennessee and two of its police officers. Police officers insisted that James Decker and his daughter, who were preaching and displaying signs, move back from the curb to continue. An argument broke out that escalated into police eventually using pepper spray on Decker. Rejecting plaintiff's free exercise claim, the court concluded that the officers were applying a neutral, generally applicable regulation prohibiting interference with traffic. It rejected plaintiff's free speech claim, finding that the regulation was a content-neutral time, place and manner restriction.