Dearborn (MI) Wrestling Coach Sues Principal Claiming Religious Bias

In Dearborn, Michigan (a city with a large Muslim population), a long-serving and "legendary" high school wrestling coach who was fired has filed a federal religious discrimination lawsuit against the principal of Fordson High School and the Dearborn school system. Plaintiff Gerald Marszalek and two of his three assistant coaches were practicing Christians. One of the assistants, volunteer coach Trey Hancock, is a Christian minister and the father of a state champion wrestler. Tensions between principal Imad Fadlallah (a Muslim) and Coach Marszalek came to a head as the result of a Muslim student's decision to convert to Christianity after attending a summer wrestling camp run separately by Trey Hancock. The principal ordered Marszalek to bar Hancock from entering Fordson High School, and ordered him not to mention Hancock or his independent wrestling club. In 2008, Fadallah terminated Marszalek as wrestling coach.

The complaint (full text) in Marszalek v. Fadlallah, (ED MI, filed 7/27/2009), alleges more broadly:

57. Defendant Fadlallah, since assuming duties as Fordson’s principal in 2005, has systematically weeded out Christian teachers, coaches, and employees, and has terminated, demoted, or reassigned them because of their Christian beliefs, expressions, and associations. Defendant Fadlallah acts in this manner because Christian beliefs are inconsistent with his personal Muslim beliefs.

58. Defendant Fadlallah has publicly stated "he sees Dearborn Fordson High School as a Muslim school, both in students and faculty, and is working to that end," or words to that effect.

The lawsuit, challenging Marszalek's firing, alleges discrimination, due process violations, and infringement of free exercise, speech and association rights under various provisions of the U.S. and Michigan constitutions. It also alleges violations of Michigan's Elliot-Larsen Civil Rights Act and a claim for tortious interference with advantageous business relationships. Yesterday's Detroit Free Press reported on the lawsuit.

A press release by the Thomas More Law Center that filed the suit on behalf of Marszalek quotes TMLC president Richard Thompson, who made a broader assertion. He said: "We are getting a glimpse of what happens when Muslims who refuse to accept American values and principles gain political power in an American community. Failure to renew coach Marszalek’s contract had nothing to do with wrestling and everything to do with religion."