Opinion Issued In Case Ordering Parochial School Student Into Public School Band

A Pennsylvania federal district court has now issued a detailed written opinion explaining the temporary restraining order it issued last week (see prior posting) requiring the the Burrell (PA) High School to permit a student who transferred to a parochial school to remain in the high school band. In Trefelner v. Burrell School District, 2009 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 78785 (WD PA, Sept. 2, 2009), the court held that the free exercise rights of Alexander Trefelner, an eighth grade saxophone player, were infringed by the school's policy. The policy, by permitting exceptions for home-schooled students and students attending charter schools, favors secular over religious motivations. The policy is not a neutral policy of general applicability. The reasons advanced for allowing home and charter schooled students to participate apply equally to parochial school students.