6th Circuit Hears Oral Arguments In Long-Running 10 Commandments Case

The 6th Circuit yesterday heard oral arguments in the long running 10-Commandments case, ACLU of Kentucky v. McCreary County. In 2005, the U.S. Supreme Court upheld a preliminary injunction barring the a display of the Ten Commandments along with other historical documents that refer to God in two Kentucky county courthouses. A majority concluded that the displays violated the Establishment Clause because the predominant purpose of the displays was the advancement of religion. (See prior posting.) However Justice Souter added: "we do not decide that the Counties' past actions forever taint any effort on their part to deal with the subject matter." Meanwhile the counties put up yet a third display, a broader "Foundations of American Law and Government" display that included the Ten Commandments along with other historical documents. On that basis, on remand the district court refused to issue a permanent injunction, but also refused to find that the counties had purged themselves of their original religious motivation. (See prior posting.) The Cincinnati Enquirer says that yesterday's oral arguments in the 6th Circuit focused on whether the counties have done enough to eliminate their original religious motivation.