Canadian Court Decides Dispute Between Church Factions Over Control of Funds

Ethiopian Orthodox Church of Canada v. Hohite Semay St. Mary Ethiopian Orthodox Tewahido Church, (BC Sup. Ct., Oct. 9, 2009), involved a dispute over which of two factions in a Vancouver congregation in the Canadian province of British Columbia was entitled to control over $280,000 of church funds. The congregation was made up primarily of immigrants from Ethiopia and Eritrea whose first language is Amharic. The dispute grew out of the firing of the congregation's priest and inaccurate corporate filings when the congregation was created that had initially registered the congregation in the name of the Toronto-based Ethiopian Orthodox Church of Canada. That Church, as plaintiff, is aligned with the smaller of the two factions in the congregation. The British Columbia Supreme Court (as a trial court) held: "the conduct of the parties shows that there was never any intention that the funds raised by and for the benefit of members of the Vancouver Church were for the beneficial ownership of the plaintiff.... The plaintiff is not, and never was, the owner of the funds at issue."