Award By Rabbinical Court Vacated Over Limit on Party's Choice of Attorney

In Kahan v. Rosner, (NY Sup. Ct., Nov. 16, 2009), a New York trial court vacated an arbitration award in a dispute between siblings over property originally owned by their father. The award was issued by a Rabbinical Court which refused to permit one of the parties to be represented by the attorney of his choice. The parties had signed a waiver providing that they would use only Rabbinical counsel acceptable to the Rabbinical court. However the state civil court held that the right to have an attorney at an arbitration proceeding is unwaivable, and the Rabbinical court had given no reason why the objecting party could not be represented by the attorney ("toayn") he had selected. [Thanks to Y.Y. Landa for the lead.]