Sanctions Imposed On Attorney In Client's Suit Against Jews For Jesus

Rapp v. Jews for Jesus, Inc. is a long running case in the state courts of Florida filed by Edith Rapp who claimed that Jews for Jesus published a false report from her missionary stepson that she had joined the organization. (See prior posting.) The courts determined that Rapp may have a cause of action for defamation by implication, and in a short decision issued last February, the state court of appeals remanded the case to the trial court, ordering Edith Rapp to "succinctly replead her claims, without excessive editorialization." Now, in an Order issued on Oct. 29 (full text), the trial court ordered Edith Rapp's attorney to pay for attorney's fees and costs incurred by defendant in arguing that the latest pleadings still contain excessive editorialization. The court concluded that the pleadings which continued to include redundant, immaterial and scandalous content that the court had previously ordered stricken involved bad faith litigation conduct on the part of plaintiff's attorney, Barry M. Silver, and not misconduct by plaintiff herself. Liberty Counsel, which is defending Jews for Jesus, yesterday issued a release on the decision.