A lawsuit has been filed in state court in Akron, Ohio seeking to prevent the Cleveland Catholic Diocese from moving ahead with its plans to close some 50 of its churches in eight counties. The closures and parish mergers are designed to save money and make better use of the Diocese's limited number of priests. According to yesterday's Cleveland Plain Dealer, Nancy McGrath, head of the newly formed group Code Purple, alleges in her lawsuit that under Ohio law, the Bishop needs consent of parishioners to close the churches. She claims that parish property is held in trust for the parish, and argues that consent of the beneficiaries is needed before the trustee can dispose of trust assets. In response, the Diocese argues that Ohio case law makes it clear that the individual members of the parish are not beneficiaries of the trust, and they have no standing to enforce the trust. It also argues that the First Amendment requires civil courts to respect decisions of hierarchical Church authorities in situations such as this.
Last month McGrath was named in a restraining order preventing her and other protesters from taking over a church in Akron scheduled for closure. The Diocese has now worked out a compromise under which protesters can remain in a Church until midnight on the day of its last Mass.
