2nd Circuit: No Right To Be Free of Selective Immigration Law Enforcement

In Turkmen v. Ashcroft, (2d Cir., Dec. 18, 2009), the U.S. 2nd Circuit Court of Appeals rejected claims by seven Arab and Muslim detainees who were in the United States illegally. The now-deported detainees argued that their period of detention before they were removed from the country was illegally prolonged so the government could investigate whether they were tied to terrorism. As reported by New York Law Journal, plaintiffs' counsel contended that the government used religion and ethnicity as a proxy for suspicion of terrorist activity in deciding to prolong plaintiffs' detention. The Second Circuit, however, dismissed plaintiffs' equal protection claims on qualified immunity grounds. It held that "plaintiffs point to no authority clearly establishing an equal protection right to be free of selective enforcement of the immigration laws based on national origin, race, or religion...."