Florida Court Says No-Aid Claim Against Faith-Based Treatment Program Can Proceed

In Council for Secular Humanism, Inc. v. McNeil, (FL Ct. App., Dec. 15, 2009), a Florida state appellate court held that plaintiffs stated a valid claim under the "no-aid" provision of Florida's Constitution (Art. I, Sec. 3) when they challenged per diem payments by the state to two Christian ministries for prisoners placed in their faith-based substance abuse transitional housing programs. At issue were contracts with Lamb of God Ministries and Prisoners of Christ. However the court held that plaintiffs' lacked taxpayer standing to assert a related claim focusing on the performance and oversight of contracts with the ministries. The court also dismissed plaintiffs' challenge to the authority given prison chaplains in the process of placing inmates in substance abuse transitional program. Yesterday's Tampa (FL) Tribune reported on the decision.