Full 9th Circuit Hears Oral Arguments In Establishment Clause Challenge To San Francisco Resolution

The U.S. 9th Circuit Court of Appeals yesterday en banc heard oral arguments in Catholic League for Religious and Civil and Rights v. City and County of San Francisco. (Audio recording of full arguments.) In June, a 3-judge panel of the 9th Circuit rejected an Establishment Clause challenge to a strongly worded resolution passed by San Francisco's Board of Supervisors. The resolution criticized a directive from Catholic Cardinal William Levada instructing Catholic social service agencies to not place children in need of adoption with same-sex couples. (See prior posting.) The San Francisco Chronicle reports on yesterday's oral arguments which focused on whether the resolution was an unconstitutional governmental attack on Catholicism, or a justifiable resolution of disapproval of a group that opposed the city's policy on equality for gays and lesbians.