Several Jewish Groups Working To Get Rid of Stupak Amendment In Health Care Bill

According to The Forward yesterday, several Jewish groups that favor abortion rights are working to keep the House-passed Stupak amendment out of the Senate version of the health care reform bill. The groups include the Religious Action Center of Reform Judaism, the National Council of Jewish Women, the American Jewish Congress and the Joint Action Committee for Political Affairs. The paper reports on an interesting argument being advanced by the groups:

The director of the Religious Action Center of Reform Judaism, Rabbi David Saperstein, said that in pushing for the stricter abortion measure, religious conservatives are using the opposite argument from their case for allowing government-subsidized school vouchers to be used for religious schools. Conservatives argue that the voucher case does not constitute government endorsement of religion because a mother or father is making the choice of where to spend the money.

But in pushing for the adoption of Stupak, proponents are saying that if the government gives an individual money for health insurance, the government is then endorsing abortion if the recipient uses her insurance to pay for such a procedure.