Jewish Groups Split On Issues In Pending Supreme Court CLS Case

An article yesterday from JTA discusses the differences of opinion within the Jewish community over which side to support in the pending Supreme Court case of Christian Legal Society v. Martinez. At issue in the case is whether the University of California's Hastings College of Law may impose its policy against discrimination on the basis of religion and sexual orientation on a student religious group seeking formal recognition. Orthodox Jewish groups have filed amicus briefs on the side of the Christian Legal Society, arguing among other things that if CLS loses, University rules would require Jewish student groups to admit Jews for Jesus proselytizers as members. On the other hand, more secular Jewish civil rights groups such as the ADL are supporting the University, concerned that otherwise government funds will be able to be used to support discriminatory activities. Various of the groups disagree over whether the case is limited to issues relating to student groups, or whether it will have broader implications for faith-based funding.