Court Upholds Rights of Evangelists To Leaflet At Catholic Parish Festival

Teesdale v. City of Chicago, (ND IL, March 17, 2010), is a suit by Garfield Ridge Baptist Church and five of its members who were prevented by police acting as security guards from handing out religious tracts, and from using a megaphone, at a Festival being held (with a city permit) by a Catholic parish on parish grounds and surrounding streets. The court held that it was a violation of plaintiff's clearly established rights to prevent them from leafleting, and that a question of fact remained as to whether preventing them from using a megaphone was reasonable. The court also refused to dismiss the false arrest claim by one of the plaintiffs who was arrested for trespassing. The court however did dismiss plaintiffs equal protection claims and their claims under the Illinois Religious Freedom Restoration Act. Preventing them from distributing literature on one afternoon at one place did not constitute a substantial burden on their religious exercise. Finally the court held that plaintiffs can proceed against the city itself only for equitable relief. Plaintiffs' attorneys issued a press release on the decision.