Appeal of Windermere Quiet Title Action Dismissed [Corrected]

Last week, a Missouri appellate court agreed with the Missouri Baptist Convention's unusual position that the appeal it filed in a case should be dismissed because the order it was appealing is not a final judgment. The decision is part of MBC's attempt to regain control of the Windermere Baptist Conference Center that, along with four other institutions, broke away from the Convention in a dispute over the fundamentalist stance of Convention leaders. After losing other attempts (see prior posting), the Conference brought a quiet title action, claiming fraud in the transfer of real estate to Windermere. The trial court dismissed the suit. In Atkins v. Jester, (MO App., April 30, 2010), the court of appeals held that the dismissal order was not properly certified for immediate appeal because the dismissal was without prejudice and was not implicitly a ruling on the merits. ABP yesterday reported on the decision. [Note: an earlier version of this posting incorrectly indicated that the decision was a defeat for MBC.]