Court Enjoins Planned Student Prayer At High School Graduation

On Friday, an Indiana federal district court issued a preliminary injunction prohibiting the planned student-led prayer at suburban Indianapolis' Greenwood High School's upcoming graduation. The school conducts a student ballot at an assembly in which students vote on whether to have a fellow student deliver a non-denominational prayer at graduation. This year's valedictorian sued challenging the practice. (See prior posting.) In Workman v. Greenwood Community School Corp., (SD IN, April 30, 2010), the court said in part:

Under the circumstances of this case, were a prayer to be permitted at the upcoming Greenwood graduation ceremony, it likely would be perceived "as a public expression of the views of the majority of the student body delivered with the approval of the school administration."... The offering of prayer at a high school graduation does not, by itself, violate the Establishment Clause. If, however, "the 'degree of school involvement makes it clear that the [graduation] prayers bear ‘the imprint of the state,' then a constitutional violation has occurred." ... The policy in place at Greenwood purposefully encourages the delivery of a majority-sanctioned prayer at a "regularly scheduled, school-sponsored function conducted on school property." ... That policy therefore violates the Constitution as an establishment of religion.

Reporting on the decision, yesterday's Indianapolis Star quotes school officials who say they will not appeal the decision and will not hold votes or attempt to hold graduation prayers in future years.