German Court Says High School Can Bar Islamic Prayer

In Germany, an appellate court yesterday held that a high school can bar a 16-year old Muslim student from performing namaz, Islamic prayer rituals, at school during his break time. Last year, the Berlin administrative court ruled that Diesterweg High School in Berlin-Wedding must allow a Muslim student known in the litigation as Yunus M. to pray 10 minutes each day in a separate classroom. (See prior posting.) An appellate court in Berlin overturned that ruling. According to Sify News, the school involved enrolls students from 29 different countries. They often argue about religious practices such as wearing of head scarves and fasting. The appellate court said that while a serious potential for conflict justified assigning the Muslim student a separate room for his prayers, the school does not have the capacity to offer the same privacy to all students who might want it. The court concluded that burdening the Muslim student's religious freedom is justified in order to protect the rights of other students and parents to freedom of belief and a calm educational environment.