Ecclesiastical Abstention Doctrine Bars Court From Deciding Governance Dispute

In Rentz v. Werner, (WA App., June 7, 2010), a Washington state appellate court held that the ecclesiastical abstention doctrine precludes the court from adjudicating a dispute between former members of the Aquarian Foundation, a spiritualist church headquartered in Seattle, Washington, and the church’s current minister. At issue is the interpretation of the church's articles of incorporation and bylaws. Plaintiffs allege that the minister improperly expelled them and others from church membership. The minister argues that she is president of the congregation and its minister for life, and that those she expelled were committing heresy. The court concluded that the issues raised in the litigation go to the core of the church's ecclesiastical affairs, and that the First Amendment protects against judicial interference in religious belief and practice whether the church is congregational or hierarchical.