Prop 8 Opponents Say CLS v. Martinez Supports Them

Earlier this month, lawyers made their closing argument in Perry v. Schwarzenegger, a federal constitutional challenge to California's Proposition 8 that bans same-sex marriage. A decision has not yet been handed down in the case. (See prior posting.) Plaintiffs, who claim that gays and lesbians are a protected class for constitutional purposes, say language in Monday's Supreme Court decision in Christian Legal Society v. Martinez supports their position. The Recorder yesterday reported that lawyers for those challenging Proposition 8 wrote a letter (full text) to U.S. District Judge Vaughn Walker, bringing the Supreme Court's language to his attention. The letter reads in part:

In Christian Legal Society, the Supreme Court definitively held that sexual orientation is not merely behavioral, but rather, that gay and lesbian individuals are an identifiable class. Writing for the Court, Justice Ginsburg explained: "Our decisions have declined to distinguish between status and conduct in this context."