Court Refuses To Enjoin Graduation Ceremonies In Church Building

In Does 1, 7, 8 and 9 v. Elmbrook Joint Common School District No. 21, (ED WI, July 19, 2010), a Wisconsin federal district court refused to permanently enjoin a Wisconsin school district from holding graduation ceremonies in a church. The court rejected the claim of unconstitutional coercion, saying: "plaintiffs unease and offense at having to attend graduation ceremonies at the Church and face religious symbols, while in no way minor, is not enough." Responding to plaintiffs' argument that the practice amounted to government endorsement of religion, the court said:

the District's decision to hold graduation ceremonies and the senior honors event in a house of worship holds symbolic force. However, considering the totality of circumstances, the reasonable observer would fairly understand that the District's use of the Church for these events is based on real and practical concerns, and not an impermissible endorsement of religion.

Finally the court also rejected plaintiffs arguments of excessive entanglement and unconstitutional use of taxpayer funds to support religion. (See prior related posting.)