Indiana Church Sues Over Landmarking of Its Building

A Cumberland, Indiana church last week filed a federal lawsuit alleging that the decision by the Indianapolis Historic Preservation Commission to designate the church's property and building as an historic area infringes the Church's free exercise rights under the U.S. and Indiana constitutions and under RLUIPA, violates its free speech rights, denies the Church equal protection of the laws and amounts to an unconstitutional bill of attainder.  The complaint (full text) in St. John United Church of Christ v. Indianapolis Historic Preservation Commission, (SD IN, Filed Sept. 10, 2010), alleges that the church has a shrinking and aging congregation, that its building needs extensive repairs and  is costly to maintain, and that the church needs a new building to attract younger members. The church had negotiated a sale of its building to developers who would use the site for new construction. The proceeds of the sale were to be used to build on another site already owned by the church. However the county prevented the sale of the building by designating it a historic landmark. A press release from the Storzer & Greene law firm announced the filing of the lawsuit.