Evangelist Sues Challenging City's Noise Ordinance

A lawsuit was filed yesterday in a Virginia federal district court by a Christian evangelist challenging Winchester, Virginia's noise ordinance.  Michael Marcavage, director of Repent America, was required by police to stop using a hand-held microphone and speaker while preaching at at Winchester's 2010 Apple Blossom Festival.  The complaint (full text) in Marcavage v. City of Winchester, Virginia, (WD VA, Nov. 3, 2010), contends that the city's ordinance that bars "any noise which unreasonably annoys, disturbs, injures or endangers the comfort, health, safety, welfare, or environment of others" is unconstitutionally vague.  The suit also alleges that the law, on its face violates the free expression provisions of the First Amendment and Virginia's Constitution as well as Virginia's Religious Freedom Restoration Act. Finally, plaintiff contends that because police acted on the basis of one person's complaint that the preaching caused the individual to be uncomfortable, the ordinance was not applied in a viewpoint neutral fashion. The Rutherford Institute issued a press release announcing the filling of the lawsuit.