Church Denied Preliminary Injunction In Zoning Dispute

In Merrimack Congregation of Jehovah's Witnesses v. Town of Merrimack, 2011 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 36090 (D NH, March 31. 2011), a New Hampshire federal district court agreed with the conclusion previously reached by a magistrate judge (see prior posting) that a Jehovah's Witness congregation was not entitled to a preliminary injunction to override a zoning denial by the Merrimack (NH) Zoning Board of Adjustment. The congregation, which wished to build a Kingdom Hall in an area zoned residential, argued that the zoning ordinance as applied to churches is an unconstitutional prior restraint. The court disagreed, holding in part that "the location of a church, absent other expressive issues, does not implicate the right to free expression." It also concluded that the zoning restriction does not burden the free exercise of religion.