Science Teacher's Appeal of Firing Remanded To State Court

In January, the Mount Vernon, Ohio Board of Education fired middle school science teacher John Freshwater on the basis of a referee's report that concluded Freshwater used his classroom to advance his Christian religious views. (See prior posting.) Pursuant to Ohio Rev. Code 3319.16, Freshwater appealed his dismissal to a state common pleas court.  The school board, invoking 28 USC 1441, sought to remove the case to federal court based on the court's federal question jurisdiction. Last week in Freshwater v. Mount Vernon City School District Board of Education, (SD OH, April 5, 2011), an Ohio federal district court invoked the Younger abstention doctrine and remanded the case to state court.  Today's Columbus Dispatch reports on the decision.